Information retrieval in pharmacy practice

16


Information retrieval in pharmacy practice





Introduction


The current era is characterized by man’s inordinate ability to store, retrieve and transmit large volumes of information using computer technology. Albert Einstein proposed that the secret of success is ‘to know where to find the information and how to use it’. Most pharmacists would probably agree. This chapter aims to provide the reader with a theoretical understanding of how to source health- and medicines-related information in the present information age. While the quality of retrieved information is considered, guidance on the detailed evaluation of what is known broadly as ‘clinical evidence’ is found elsewhere (see Ch. 20).


In the GPhC’s Standards of conduct, ethics and performance, the knowledge and provision of health- and medicines-related information, specifically, is considered in the following manner. In relation to their own knowledge and competence, pharmacists must develop their skills in-line with their area of expertise, keeping up-to-date with relevant progress through CPD (see Ch. 6). In relation to the provision of medicines-related information to those who want or need it, pharmacists are expected to be able to provide accurate, reliable, impartial, relevant and up-to-date information.


Yet with thousands of medicinal products, dressings and appliances on the UK market, pharmacists are highly unlikely to hold in-depth knowledge of all health- and medicines-related issues at all times. Therefore, the ability to retrieve relevant health- and medicines-related information in a timely and efficient manner becomes central to the practice of all pharmacy professionals (Box 16.1).




Where does information exist and how can it be retrieved?


Information retrieval is the tracing and recovery of stored information. Information can range from patient information to drug monographs, to more sophisticated health technology assessments. It can exist in many forms from the archives of a drug company to the worldwide web. Effective information retrieval requires an understanding of the range of relevant information available, where it exists and how it might be sourced.


Pharmacists sourcing information are likely to use the internet at some point during their search. The expanse of information on the Web and its apparent accessibility has integrated the internet into most work routines. While, on the whole, the seemingly endless material may not suit most pharmacists’ information needs, there are specific online resources that pharmacists can browse. These include websites operated by governments, professional, practice, regulatory or academic bodies, as well as websites belonging to patient groups and the pharmaceutical industry. However, the fluid nature of the internet, the vast array of information available, plus the variable nature of each query will probably involve pharmacists in some degree of internet searching. This necessitates an understanding of search engines and search strategies. There are databases on the net and on CD-ROM which act as directories for scientific papers and other publications and, as such, can be used to search for available material.


Before widespread use of the internet, the principal source of health-related information was the printed book. Books still contain a vast array of indispensable information and reputable ones play a vital role in information management. Although individual pharmacies may not keep the full range of essential books, specialist centres will have access to these and to other resources.




The web address


The term ‘website’ is used to denote a set of themed, linked web pages, usually accessed via a ‘homepage’. Web pages are written in hypertext markup language (htm/html). A web page is a collection of text, graphics, sounds and/or video that corresponds to a single window of scrollable material. Web pages are stored on a web server, which hosts the website and ‘dispenses’ the pages in response to a web browser. The web browser displays web pages after communicating with the server. There are a large number of browsers.


Each page on the web has a distinct web address known as the uniform resource locator (URL). The URL can be a good clue as to the quality of the information found on a website. The ‘locator’ in URL can also give an indication of where one is within a website and indicate the source of the information being viewed.


A web address or website name appears on the address bar. All website names are part of the domain name system (DNS) and look similar to this: http://www.dh.gov.uk/.


Box 16.2 breaks down this address and examines the individual parts.



Box 16.2   Individual components of a typical domain name system



A web address: http://www.gov.uk/government/publications


PROTOCOL. http:// shows us that we are looking at a website with http meaning ‘hypertext transfer protocol’, the set of rules used by the computer to access and deliver web pages. The variation https:// indicates a secure connection to the site in question


SERVER AND ORGANIZATION’S NAME. www.dh informs us that we are viewing a website held on a computer or a web server known as www belonging to an organization called ‘dh’, in this instance the Department of Health


DOMAIN AND COUNTRY. gov.uk tells us that we are looking at the website of the UK government. This part of the web address is the ‘domain’, other examples of which are .edu (educational); .com (commercial); .co (a company); .ac (academic); .org (non-governmental, non-profit making organizations). Sometimes domains are followed by a country code that indicates the location of the computer holding the website


PATHNAME AND DOCUMENT NAME. Beyond the homepage of an organization’s website, other pages are ordered in a hierarchy of folders. In this example, /government/publications indicates we are looking at a folder in which we will find another folder containing publications


FILE EXTENSION. The file extension usually identifies the type of data found in the file. For example, the extension .htm (or .html) indicates a file that contains code expressed in the hypertext markup language used to develop pages that are to be placed on the web. There are countless other examples; the extension .txt indicates a file containing textual data; the extension .pdf indicates a file in portable document format.



Directory of useful websites


Table 16.1 provides a list of some of the established health-related websites, although web addresses or pathnames can change or more useful sites can be created. To help order the directory, similar websites are grouped together. The list is not exhaustive and it should be used as a starting point.




Bookmarking


Once a number of relevant websites have been identified and authenticated for inclusion, these can be stored as a saved text file, using hyperlinks to connect each typed URL address in the document to the address bar on the browser and therefore the desired web destination. Hyperlinks are, usually, in a different colour to the rest of the document or are underlined and can be activated by a mouse click.


Hyperlinks provide a way of finding and bookmarking useful websites. Websites normally have a directory of related websites as ‘links’.


An accepted method of bookmarking relevant pages is to use an internet browser with functions such as ‘Favourites’. A marker points at a website which then enables the user to quickly return to that site without having to remember and type in its URL. Browsers usually offer the facility for organizing the bookmarks into folders and subfolders.


There are also innovations such as the social bookmarking website http://delicious.com/, which provides a means of storing personal bookmarks online instead of within the browser, thus enabling bookmark information to be accessed and shared online.



Searching the internet


Accessing a list of useful websites and following the links therein is one approach to finding information on the internet, but is unlikely to be productive unless the query falls specifically within the remit of a known website. With the web containing over 40 billion pages, at some point it is likely that the website containing the required information is simply unknown to the user and it has not been possible to reach it via ‘browsing’ the internet. For that reason, it is essential to have a good appreciation of internet search options.



Commercial search engines


The internet is not controlled or owned by any individual or organization, and plays host to a multitude of material with limitless authors. The manner in which information is stored on the internet is quite unique. There is no central catalogue of the internet.


A variety of websites concentrate on providing internet search facilities. Some are set up as web portals with the aim of providing a complete resource for everything on the web that they consider to be worthwhile. Portals display their own editorial material, news headlines and other up-to-date information, as well as links to commercial partners and paid advertisements. They are good for general or commercial information but most will fail to identify websites for non-profit organizations, such as the NHS. Web portals also provide a search facility. Search engines attempt to search all the text on all the pages of the web. Software seeks out and indexes web pages, storing the results in sizeable databases. When a user types a query, the search engine searches its database for pages that contain words matching the query and displays the results as a list of links (Box 16.3). Each search engine ranks results according to its own criteria and so different search engines can give different results for the same query.




Effective use of search engines


Before beginning a new search, the user should take time to consider what they already know, knowledge gaps and information required. It is advisable to have a plan that focuses the search. The user should select a set of keywords that best reflect the information need and narrow the search to a particular subject or topic. Results should be compared to the original information need. If appropriate material is found on the first page of the search then the activity need go no further. It is important to know when to stop searching, especially when there is limited time.


When, however, the results do not match the information need, it is advisable to pause and reflect. The user should consider what they are searching for; can the search be refined by changing keywords, perhaps adding, taking away or replacing them? The keywords must match the information needed. One additional approach is to subtract any redundant words from the search query. These include words such as ‘a’, ‘an’, ‘the’, ‘and’, etc. It might also be helpful to rearrange the search so that the more important search terms are placed first, to give more influence when the results are ranked.


Boolean terms for academic databases are described in more detail later. In Google™, the Boolean terms AND and NOT are not used in the traditional sense. Google™ will automatically link a series of words using the AND operator, instead of NOT, to eliminate a word from the results. A space should be left after the word that is needed and a minus sign (−) should be typed immediately before the word that is to be excluded. The term OR can, however, be used in Google™ by typing OR between the words. Google™ can also be forced to link words by using a plus sign (+), especially where one of the words is a common word that might normally be ignored. The search engine can also be asked to search for a string of words in a particular order, e.g. ‘Community-acquired pneumonia’. The user should examine search engine tools to make the most of any advanced features. Sometimes, the search engine itself may need to be changed or the basis of the search re-examined.


It is important to recognize that search engines do not necessarily index the whole of each document they retrieve. A search engine may upload each page in full, but it may only use the first few thousand characters for indexing and so vital information further down the web page will escape being indexed. Where a search engine does return a link to a site, sometimes it is not possible to access the content if the user is behind their organization’s ‘firewall’. Search engines do not locate everything on the web first-hand. It might be that a general search engine finds another site that is a more appropriate starting point, for example a health services directory. In that way, the search is narrowed automatically.


Some public web pages are protected from search engines through use of a file (robots.txt) that blocks access to the robot. This normally relates to personal, sensitive, interactive, timely or premium (subscription, or paid for) content. Another place that search engines cannot always reach is commercial data collections, or collections of valuable, copyrighted content, such as subscription-based academic journal databases and other specialized databases, information in professional directories, patents and news articles.



Assessing the quality of information on the web


There is no restriction on what is placed on the web or by whom. There is certainly no process of editorial or peer review for material placed on the web. Apart from the Advertising Standards Authority, which recently gained the authority to regulate marketing material on UK websites, no UK organization is currently responsible for regulating health- and medicines-related information on the internet. Under these conditions, there is always the danger that an internet site contains incomplete, inaccurate, irrelevant, obsolete or even hoax information. As a result, the utmost care should be taken in making use of health-related information from the internet. An informed approach must include a system for evaluating the quality of the information found against the intended use of that information. Factors listed below can all affect the quality of an information source; they are not mutually exclusive and must be considered in combination (see Table 16.2).



Table 16.2


Evaluating the quality of an internet-based website for health- and medicines-related information
























Activity Purpose
Follow internal links To find out as much as possible about the resource, e.g. the scope of the material; the intended audience and coverage; the origin of the information; who is responsible for the content; involvement of others in the production of material; any access restrictions
Analyse the URL To find out where the information comes from and to judge if they are qualified to provide the information, e.g. the individual or group that has taken responsibility for the website
Examine the information contained To find out the subjects and types of materials covered; comprehensiveness of coverage; notable omissions; notable indicators of accuracy; editorial procedures; research basis to the information; creation date; the frequency and/or regularity of any updating
Consider the presentation To find out if the resource is frequently unavailable or noticeably slow to access; any access restrictions (e.g. by geographical region, hardware/software requirements); whether there is a registration procedure and whether this is straightforward; whether the available content is free or subscription based; the copyright statement and copyright restrictions; whether the site is particularly difficult or easy to use; presence or absence of user support facilities and/or help information
Obtain additional information To find out if an individual or group has taken responsibility for the website; whether they are qualified to provide this information; whether the resource is well known (e.g. recommended via links), reviewed and/or heavily used
Compare with other similar websites To find out if a resource is unique in terms of content or format and any differences between mirror and original sites for the same materials
< div class='tao-gold-member'>

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 24, 2016 | Posted by in PHARMACY | Comments Off on Information retrieval in pharmacy practice

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access