Vaccines for Methamphetamine Use Disorder



Fig. 5.1
Pooled antibody titer levels measured by ELISA on sera samples obtained from weeks 2 through 21 after the initial vaccination with SMA-TT with alum alone as adjuvant are presented. The arrow at week 3 indicates the time that a vaccination boost was administered



While high antibody levels are critical for efficacy, they are not sufficient to establish whether a vaccine construct has good potential for further study. The affinity of the antibodies should also be assessed. That is, it is important to know how well the antibodies bind to the antigen, such as MA. This affinity of the polyclonal antibody response can be assessed by a variety of techniques, but the important concepts are that these polyclonal antibodies will have multiple affinities rather than a single affinity and the amount of each of these antibodies together will determine the efficacy of this mix of antibodies. In our studies, we have found that our vaccines produce up to 20% high-affinity antibodies and 80% moderate-affinity. From our calculations these moderate-affinity antibodies are sufficient to bind the MA before it can enter the brain, and our assessment of brain levels of MA after vaccination indicates a fourfold reduction in MA levels, as blood levels rise (Haile et al., in submission).



5.4.2 Functional Tests


The next step in preclinical research on vaccines for addiction is to test if there are functional effects. That is, it is important to see that vaccinated animals show different, often seen as attenuated, behavioral or physiological responses to the administration of the target drug. While this may seem straightforward, it is often not. Drugs of abuse have multiple effects and most of these can differ by the dose administered. In addition, many of these responses will change with repeated drug administration. When an increase in a response to a drug is seen with repeated administration, this is considered sensitization. Sensitization is also seen by demonstrating that lower doses produce a response that would be seen in a drug-naive animal given a higher dose under acute conditions. Conversely, some drug responses decrease with repeated administration, a phenomenon called tolerance. Tolerance is also seen by demonstrating that higher doses are needed to produce a response that would be seen in a drug-naive animal given a lower dose under acute conditions. Further complicating the picture is that the dose-response function of a specific drug rarely appears to be linear with increasing response levels induced by increasing doses. In some cases, an increase in dose produces an effect that masks or interferes with the expression of the response under study. The net effect will look like a response to a lower dose. Thus, it is very important to test the function of a vaccine with multiple doses of the drug and include the appropriate control groups or conditions.

Various functional assays have been used in the preclinical assessments of MA vaccines. Since MA affects locomotor activity and this is easily measured in a standard, commercially available apparatus, it is usually the first behavior to examine. Other tests can be used to evaluate the addictive properties of MA. These include conditioned place preference (CPP) and operant self-administration. And both of these procedures can be used to assess acquisition and reinstatement of the behavior. The latter effect is particularly significant because it is thought to be a model of relapse to drug use after abstinence in humans (Shaham et al. 2003). Other functional assessments of the efficacy of MA vaccines that have been used include measuring body temperature and the discriminative stimulus effects of MA.



5.5 Results of Studies with MA Vaccines


We have assessed antibody titers in response to various conjugate MA vaccine preparations. In one study (Shen et al. 2013a), we found good levels of antibodies in response to SMA-KLH prepared with MPL as the adjuvant. Mice were vaccinated and given boosters at 3 and 20 weeks after the initial vaccination. Measures of antibody titers were at a peak level by 6 weeks and remained at about this level through week 18 post-initial vaccination. The levels increased after the second booster and remained high through week 35. In another study, we prepared SMA with another carrier protein, TT, and used aluminum as the adjuvant (Haile et al., in submission). Mice were vaccinated and given a booster at week 3. The antibody titers were measured at several time points for 21 weeks following the first vaccination with a single booster at week 3. The antibody levels increase greatly after the boost given at week 3 to 100K at week 4 and to their highest levels of about 200K from weeks 6 to 8. The levels then modestly declined to 125K at week 15 and to 100K at week 21.

We find that about 3–4% of mice do not produce antibodies to MA with these vaccines even when the TLR4 or TLR5 adjuvants are included. In humans this challenge of immunological non-response has also occurred, and our cocaine vaccine produced very poor antibody responses in 10–25% of subjects (Kosten et al. 2014; Martell et al. 2009). However, these human studies only had aluminum as an adjuvant, and with these newer TLR4 and TLR5 adjuvants added to the aluminum, we expect fewer of these poorly responsive subjects.

We examined the functional effects of an SMA-KLH vaccine and an SMA-TT vaccine in mice on locomotor activity and in CPP using active immunization procedures. Mice vaccinated with SMA-KLH showed reduced conditioned effects of MA (e.g., approach behaviors) and reduced locomotor activity in response to MA but did not show a decrease in acquisition of MA CPP (Shen et al. 2013a). In our unpublished study with active immunization using SMA-TT in mice, we also did not find a significant decrease in the acquisition of MA CPP. However, reinstatement of the behavior was significantly altered (Haile et al., in submission). In fact, the vaccine appeared to have enhanced the aversive effects of repeated exposures to higher doses of MA because these mice actually showed a significant avoidance of the MA-paired environment. This enhanced aversion may reflect a more sustained MA effect from the buffering and retention of the MA in the blood from its binding to the anti-MA antibodies. Stated differently, the acute surge in relatively lower levels of MA produces preference and reinforcing effects, while the sustained increase in higher MA levels produces aversion and the negative effects described by humans as anxiety, nervousness, and even paranoia (Kosten et al. 2012).

Monoclonal MA antibodies passively administered to rats or pigeons decreased the locomotor activating and discriminative stimulus effects of MA as well as reduced self-administration behavior (Byrnes-Blake et al. 2005; McMillan et al. 2002, 2004). However, in another study with rats, an anti-MA vaccine linked to KLH did not alter the locomotor effects of a 3 mg/kg dose of MA (Byrnes-Blake et al. 2001), and another study reported enhanced the acquisition of MA self-administration (Duryee et al. 2009).

Anti-MA vaccines may be effective for specific behavioral or physiological responses to MA within certain dose ranges. A different anti-MA vaccine also linked to KLH did not affect rectal temperature or locomotor activity unless a very high dose (5.6 mg/kg) was administered (Miller et al. 2013). Additionally, in the locomotor assay, the stereotypic effects of MA were blocked; but no group differences were seen at MA doses of 3.2 mg/kg or less. It is possible that the discrepancies across studies are due to a species difference or perhaps to differences in vaccine preparations or even due to behavioral assessment procedures. Nonetheless, data from our studies support the ability of anti-MA vaccine to attenuate conditioned reward in mice.


5.6 Conclusions and Future Directions


Overall, several animal studies suggest that immunotherapy for MA abuse is a viable treatment approach. Further research is needed to determine the most effective anti-MA vaccine construct by using multiple behavioral and physiological assays. In particular, tests using MA self-administration would provide important information on whether the vaccine can attenuate the reinforcing effects of MA that maintain addictive behavior or block drug-induced reinstatement of extinguished self-administration behavior, an important model of relapse.


Acknowledgments

This research was supported by grant DP1DA033502 from the National Institute on Drug Abuse (TRK), the Alkek Foundation for Experimental Therapeutics (TAK), and the Department of Veterans Affairs (TRK).


References



Burdelya LG, Krivokrysenko VI, Tallent TC, Strom E, Gleiberman AS, Gupta D, Kurnasov OV, Fort FL, Osterman AL, Didonato JA, Feinstein E, Gudkov AV. An agonist of toll-like receptor 5 has radioprotective ability in mouse and primate models. Science. 2008;320:226–30.PubMedCentralPubMedCrossRef

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Oct 21, 2016 | Posted by in GENERAL SURGERY | Comments Off on Vaccines for Methamphetamine Use Disorder

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access