Measuring Health Care Quality in Surgery: Strategies, Limitations, and Currently Available Initiatives


Program Name

Established

Scope

Target audience

Surgery-specific

Financial incentives

Level of reporting

Data type

VA NSQIP

1994

National – VA

VA hospitals

Yes

No

Hospital

Clinical registry

ACS NSQIP

2001/2005

National

Member hospitals

Yes

No

Hospital

Clinical registry

Michigan Surgical Quality Collaborative (MSQC)

2005

Regional – MI

Member hospitals, purchasers

Yes

No/indirect

Hospital

Clinical registry

Washington Surgical Clinical Outcomes Assessment Program (SCOAP)

2006

Regional – WA

Hospitals, physicians, patients

Yes

No

Hospital

Clinical registry

Society for Thoracic Surgeons

1989

National

Hospitals, patients, purchasers

Yes

No/indirect

Hospital

Clinical registry

Leapfrog Group

2000

National

Hospitals, patients, purchasers

No

Indirect

Hospital

Survey, admin

NY Cardiac Surgery Reporting System

1989

Regional – NY

Hospitals, patients

Yes

Indirect

Hospital, surgeon

Admin

CA Hospital Outcomes Project (CHOP)

1991

Regional – CA

Hospitals, patients

No

Indirect

Hospital

Admin

PA Health Care Cost Containment Council Cardiac Care Report Card

1992

Regional – PA

Hospitals, patients

Yes

Indirect

Hospital, surgeon

Admin

CMS Hospital Compare

2003

National

Patients, hospitals, CMS

No

Direct

Hospital

Admin, registry

University HealthSystem Consortium

1984

National

Member hospitals

No

No/indirect

Hospital

Admin



There are also a number of other programs and collaborations measuring surgical quality using clinical data. These include but are not limited to the Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS), the Michigan Surgical Quality Collaborative (MSQC), the Surgical Clinical Outcomes Assessment Program (SCOAP) from Washington State, and the New York State Adult Cardiac Surgery program. Like ACS NSQIP, each program has unique strengths and weaknesses. The STS and the New York State Adult Cardiac Surgery program focus on cardiac and thoracic surgery and therefore collect risk-adjustment variables and outcomes specific to those operations. MSQC and SCOAP are regional programs that offer hospitals within a state an opportunity to work together on quality improvement initiatives.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 19, 2017 | Posted by in GENERAL SURGERY | Comments Off on Measuring Health Care Quality in Surgery: Strategies, Limitations, and Currently Available Initiatives

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access