CHAPTER 3 INTRODUCTION TO CLINICAL NUTRITION
CONSEQUENCES OF POOR NUTRITION
Nutrition plays a vital role in the health of both individuals and society, with poor nutrition and inadequate intake having a devastating effect. Overall, it has been estimated that more than 60% of all deaths in Australia result from nutrition-related disorders, such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes and cancer (Sydney-Smith 2000).
MORTALITY RISK: CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE AND CANCER
Atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease is the most common cause of death in most Western countries (Anderson 2003). In Australia, it is the leading cause of death, accounting for 34% of all deaths in 2006. Cardiovascular disease kills one Australian nearly every 10 minutes according to the Australian Heart Foundation website. It is well known that dietary factors such as carbohydrate and fat intake affect several important physiological parameters and risk factors, such as hypertension, lipid levels, diabetes and antioxidant status. With the exception of tobacco consumption, diet is probably the most important factor in the aetiology of human cancers, responsible for around one-third of all cases (Ferguson 2002). Diet-related cancers have often been considered to relate to exogenous carcinogens; however, it is increasingly apparent that many carcinogens may be endogenously generated, and that diet plays an important role in modifying this process (Ferguson 1999).
Overeating and poorly balanced meals have also led to significant increases in metabolic syndrome (syndrome X) and obesity, which are now major health concerns. A 2003 review stated that the World Health Organization estimates there are one billion people around the world who are now overweight or obese, and that 20–25% of the adult population in the USA have metabolic syndrome (Keller & Lemberg 2003).
Although overweight and obesity in adulthood is associated with decreased longevity, and the link with cardiovascular disease is well known, a recent series of meta-analyses revealed statistically significant associations for overweight with the incidence of type II diabetes, all cancers (except oesophageal [female], pancreatic and prostate), asthma, gall-bladder disease, osteoarthritis and chronic back pain (Guh et al 2009). It has further been established that obesity is associated with increased death rates from cancer (Peeters et al 2003). A large prospective study of more than 900,000 people found that a BMI above 40 was associated with a higher combined death rate from all cancers of 52% for obese men and 62% for obese women, compared with people of normal weight (Calle et al 2003). The adverse effects of obesity on health are not limited to adults. Overweight children and adolescents are now being diagnosed with impaired glucose tolerance and type 2 diabetes, and show early signs of insulin resistance syndrome and cardiovascular risk (Goran et al 2003).
A large body of research exists that attempts to isolate the influence of individual food groups and nutrients on morbidity and mortality. Research with macronutrients has found that the consumption of diets rich in plant-derived foods, wholegrains and fish reduces the risk of morbidity and mortality. However, numerous surveys have identified inadequate intakes of these foods in many Australian subpopulations (Barzi et al 2003, He et al 2002, Mozaffarian et al 2003, Rissanen et al 2003, Slavin 2003). The relative roles of micronutrients, phytochemicals and non-nutrients are still under debate.
FOOD UNDER THE MICROSCOPE
More than 25,000 different bioactive components are thought to occur in the foods consumed by human beings (Milner 2008). These components represent a veritable cocktail of chemicals that includes macronutrients (such as carbohydrates, protein, fat, water and fibre) and micronutrients (such as vitamins and minerals as well as phytochemicals), many of which are health-promoting, plant-based compounds. Additives such as preservatives, colourings and flavourings, together with contaminants introduced through farming or processing techniques, may also be present.
MACRONUTRIENTS
Lipids
The term ‘lipid’ is a generic one used to describe a number of chemicals that share two main characteristics: they are insoluble in water and contain fatty acids. When they are solid at room temperature, they are called fats, whereas those that are liquids are called oils. Fatty acids are the simplest form of lipids, and more than 40 different types occur in nature (Wahlqvist et al 1997). Of all the various classes of lipids, only precursors of the omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids are considered essential, meaning they are necessary in the diet to maintain health. The amount of dietary fat ingested and the ratios between saturated, monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids are important influences on overall health and disease.
Protein
Amino acids can be divided into two broad groups: essential or non-essential. There are nine essential amino acids that must be ingested through the diet to maintain health. Protein foods that contain all nine essential amino acids are also referred to as complete protein sources (e.g. animal protein). By contrast, almost all plant foods are incomplete protein sources, with the possible exception of spirulina and soy. During times of growth, tissue repair or pronounced catabolism, such as after surgery, the body requires additional protein for efficient new tissue growth to occur. There is also emerging evidence that supplementation with individual amino acids produces a variety of pharmacological effects that can be manipulated to provide therapeutic benefits. Several of these amino acids are reviewed in the monograph section.
MICRONUTRIENTS
Phytochemicals
Nutrients | |
Micronutrients | |
Macronutrients | |
Phytochemicals | Bioflavonoids, carotenoids, isoflavones, glutathione, lipoic acid, caffeic acid, ferulic acid, lignans, allyl sulfides, indoles |
Non-nutrients | |
Food additives: natural or synthetic | |
Contaminants |
Source: Wahlqvist et al 1997, Wardlaw 1997
FOOD LABELS
For further information about labelling, see Food Standards Australia New Zealand website at http://www.foodstandards.gov.au/thecode/.
Additives are listed as either numbers, known as additive codes, or by name. Up-to-date lists of the food additives found in Australian and New Zealand food products can be located at <www.foodstandards.gov.au>.
NUTRITIONAL DEFICIENCIES
PRIMARY DEFICIENCY
Inadequate dietary intake
The Australian National Nutrition Survey (NNS) conducted in 1995 found that approximately 30% of 2–7-year-old children ate no fruit or vegetables. Among 8–11-year-olds, 44% of boys and 38% of girls ate no fruit on the previous day and approximately one in four older children consumed no vegetables. Additionally, neither age group consumed the minimum number of serves of dairy products (Cashel 2000). Later results from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare in 1998 reported that approximately one in two Australian children under 12 were not eating fruit or fruit products, and more than one in five consumed no vegetables in a typical day.
The dietary intakes of adults are also far from ideal. The 1995 NNS also found that approximately 44% of adult males and 34% of females did not consume fruit in the 24 hours preceding the survey, and 20% of males and 17% of females did not consume vegetables (Giskes et al 2002).
Surveys of individual vitamin and mineral intakes also identify a number of at-risk subpopulations. Calcium intakes for 1045 randomly selected Australian women (20–92 years) as estimated by questionnaire showed that 76% of women aged 20–54 years, 87% of older women and 82% of lactating women had intakes below the recommended dietary intake (Pasco et al 2000). Of these, 14% had less than the minimum requirement of 300 mg/day and would, therefore, be in negative calcium balance and at risk of bone loss. The 1997 New Zealand National Nutrition Survey found that 20% of all New Zealanders and one in four women had calcium intakes below the UK estimated average requirements, and 15–20% of women aged 15–18 years were considered to have frank deficiency (Horwath et al 2001).
Surveys in Australia and New Zealand report that many adolescent girls have insufficient dietary intakes of iron and zinc to meet their high physiological requirements for growing body tissues, expanding red cell mass, and onset of menarche (Gibson et al 2002).
Evidence of deficiency in Australia and New Zealand
For example, several local surveys have found that mild to moderate iodine deficiency is more prevalent than once thought (Li et al 2001). This is of great concern because mild iodine deficiency during childhood and pregnancy has the potential to impair neurological development. One survey of Sydney schoolchildren, healthy adult volunteers, pregnant women and patients with diabetes found that all four groups had urinary iodine excretion values below those set by the World Health Organization for iodine repletion (Li et al 2001). Another survey of 225 children in Tasmania identified evidence of mild iodine deficiency in 25% of boys and 21% of girls (Guttikonda et al 2002). A research group at Monash Medical Centre in Melbourne screened 802 pregnant women and found that 48.4% of Caucasian women had urinary iodine concentrations below 50 micrograms/L compared to 38.4% of Vietnamese women and 40.8% of Indian/Sri Lankan women (Hamrosi et al 2005). These figures are disturbing when one considers that normal levels are over 100 micrograms/L, mild deficiency is diagnosed at 51–100 micrograms/L and moderate to severe deficiency at < 50 micrograms/L (Gunton et al 1999). A study conducted at a Sydney hospital involving 81 women attending a ‘high risk’ clinic found moderate to severe iodine deficiency in 19.8% of volunteers and mild iodine deficiency in another 29.6% (Gunton et al 1999).
In Australia and New Zealand, the prevalence of vitamin D deficiency varies, but it is now acknowledged to be much higher than previously thought (Nowson & Margerison 2002). The groups at greatest risk are dark-skinned and veiled women (particularly in pregnancy), their infants, and older persons living in residential care. The study by Nowson andMargerison found marginal deficiency in 23% of women, and another frank deficiency in 80% of dark-skinned women in Australia. A study conducted in a large aged-care facility in Auckland identified frank vitamin D deficiency in 49% of elderly participants in midwinter and in 33% in midsummer (Ley et al 1999). Even in studies of ‘healthy’ adults, vitamin D insufficiency has been found to affect more than 40% of residents in Queensland (Kimlin et al 2007, van der Mei et al 2007) and over 65% of Tasmanians (van der Mei et al 2007).