CHAPTER 21 Vulva, vagina and cervix
normal cytology, hormonal and inflammatory conditions
Introduction
The foundations for the success of cytological screening for cervical cancer were laid by two publications; Bales in 1927 and Papanicolaou in 1928 in which the morphology of cervical cancer cells in vaginal samples was described.1 Since then, the morphological spectrum of squamous and glandular abnormalities in cervical cytology has expanded to include pre-cancerous and invasive cervical tumours as well as tumours with origin elsewhere in the female genital tract and metastases from extra-genital sites. Crucial to the recognition of these cells is an understanding of normal vulval, vaginal, cervical and endometrial cytology, including hormonal and inflammatory/reactive conditions. The morphology of these cells is similar whether assessing conventional direct smears or newer liquid-based cytology preparations. Cytological findings in cervical neoplasia and other genital tract neoplasms are covered in Chapters 23–27.
Gross and microscopic anatomy
The basic structure of the female genital tract is depicted diagrammatically in Figure 21.1, illustrating the different types of lining epithelium that may be seen in cytological samples from various sites.
Vulva
The labia majora and minora of the vulva are covered by keratinising squamous epithelium (Fig. 21.2) which undergoes very little hormonal change during the menstrual cycle. The outer surfaces of the labia majora are hair-bearing. The inner surfaces have many sebaceous glands and apocrine sweat glands, the secretions of which provide protection against infection and local damage to the skin.
Fig. 21.2 Vulval skin showing stratified squamous keratinising epithelium with skin appendages (H&E).
Vagina
Developmentally, the upper two-thirds of the vagina is formed by fusion of the two mullerian ducts in utero. The tube thus formed differentiates into the uterus and cervix above and unites distally with the urogenital sinus to form the vagina. Thus the lower third of the vagina has a different embryological origin from the upper two-thirds. The importance of this dual derivation lies in the fact that the mullerian epithelium in the upper two-thirds is initially columnar in type, but undergoes metaplasia in utero to squamous mucosa on exposure to the acid pH of the vagina. Normally the change to squamous epithelium is complete, but the process may be interrupted, leading to persistence of glandular tissue in the adult vagina, a condition known as vaginal adenosis (see Fig. 21.99).
Under normal conditions, the vagina is lined by stratified squamous non-keratinising epithelium throughout (Fig. 21.3), usually showing no hair follicles, sweat glands or sebaceous glands to weaken its surface. The mucosa is subject to cyclical changes under the influence of the sex hormones.
Cervix
The cervix is a cylindrical fibromuscular structure of variable length, within which lies the endocervical canal connecting the body of the uterus at the internal os with the vagina at the external os. The lower portion of the cervix protrudes into the vagina, forming the anterior, posterior and two lateral fornices in the upper vagina where pooling of secretions and exfoliated cells occurs. The outer aspect of the cervix, known as the ectocervix or portio vaginalis, is covered by squamous mucosa in continuity with vaginal epithelium distally and with the lining of the endocervix at or near the external os (Fig. 21.4).
The endocervical canal is not exposed to the vaginal pH and therefore retains its glandular lining of tall columnar epithelium, with an inconspicuous layer of reserve cells beneath. resting on basement membrane. The glandular mucosa forms branching crypts that extend into the stroma of the cervix in a racemose pattern for a distance of up to 5 mm; the orifices facing distally. The canal itself is narrow, being only a few millimetres wide, and in health, is filled by a plug of mucus. During the menstrual cycle the physical properties of the cervical mucus change. Prior to ovulation the mucus is dilute, and when spread on to a slide and dried, it forms a fern-like pattern (Fig. 21.5). After ovulation, the mucus becomes thicker and no longer demonstrates ferning.
Squamocolumnar junction and transformation zone
After puberty, the location of the squamocolumnar junction changes as the cervix alters in shape. The endocervical mucosa of the lower canal, including the underlying crypts, is everted and comes to lie on the ectocervical aspect of the cervix, resulting in an ectropion or ectopy (Fig. 21.6). An ectropion is clinically visible as a reddened zone extending out from the external os. It is sometimes mistakenly called an erosion, although no actual ulceration is present and the condition is physiological.
Endocervical eversion is followed by progressive metaplasia of the exposed mucosa to more protective squamous epithelium under the influence of the vaginal pH, the term metaplasia referring to a change from one type of epithelium to another. The metaplastic process arises in the reserve cell population that normally replenishes the columnar epithelium. Instead, these reserve cells differentiate as immature squamous metaplastic cells beneath the single layer of columnar cells on the surface (Fig. 21.7A).
The metaplastic layers increase and mature progressively to form a new normal squamous mucosa indistinguishable from the original squamous epithelium of the ectocervix. The underlying endocervical crypts remain facing on to the ectocervix as a permanent marker of the site of the original squamocolumnar junction and this can be recognised colposcopically as well as in histological section (Fig. 21.7B). Glands with orifices obstructed by the metaplastic process are prone to distend with mucus, even becoming visible macroscopically as rounded nodules on the ectocervix, known as nabothian follicles.
Cytological identification of epithelial cells
Basal cells
These small primitive cells are parent to all the cells in the squamous mucosa that migrate to the surface, die and exfoliate. They are difficult to recognise in a smear with confidence and are likely to be sampled only rarely due to their deep position in the mucosa and their firm attachment to the basement membrane. They are said to occur in short rows of small regular cells with sparse green cytoplasm, oval nuclei and a high nuclear/cytoplasmic (N:C) ratio. The chromatin pattern is fine and several chromocentres may be present.2
Superficial cells (Fig. 21.11)
Cells from the granular layer, if formed, display small dark blue keratohyaline granules evenly distributed in the cytoplasm. Nests and aggregates of benign squamous cells known as epithelial pearls and rafts are sometimes seen in normal smears (Figs 21.12, 21.13).
Endocervical cells (Fig. 21.15)
Sometimes cilia are visible, staining pink with eosin, attached to the terminal bar at the luminal pole of the cell (Fig. 21.17). Cilia are more commonly seen postmenopausally but may also arise with tuboendometrioid metaplasia which can occur in the process of healing of the cervical mucosa after injury such as post-conisation.
Occasionally endocervical cell cytoplasm may become distended by mucus producing a goblet cell appearance. Care should always be taken to examine the overall morphology of these cell groups to exclude the rare possibility of intestinal-type glandular intraepithelial neoplasia (see Ch. 24) (Fig. 21.18) Background mucus from endocervical cells stains variably, either faintly green or tinged with pink. The amount of mucus present in a sample, its quality and distribution also vary considerably (Fig. 21.19). With conventional smears a ‘ferning’ effect may be evident at the time of ovulation (Fig. 21.20). This pattern is not seen with liquid-based cytology preparations.
Endocervical cells may show considerable variation in nuclear size within a group, although the polarity is maintained (Fig. 21.21).
Metaplastic cells
These cells are a normal constituent of smears from the cervical os once the transformation zone has developed (Fig. 21.22). While immature, they do not exfoliate spontaneously but can be lifted from the surface of the cervix by the abrading action of a spatula or brush. With progressive maturation, the cells increasingly resemble intermediate and superficial cells from the original ectocervix and therefore cannot be recognised as a separate cell population in cervical samples.
The cytoplasmic projections that give a spidery contour to the single cells result from their forcible removal during sample taking. In metaplastic cell sheets the cytoplasmic projections may appear as fine intercellular bridges (Fig. 21.23). In the unstable environment of the transformation zone, premature keratinisation of these cells may occur and the cytoplasm is then a deep orange colour. Other degenerative changes such as vacuolation and the presence of intracytoplasmic polymorphs may be seen, even in the absence of significant inflammation. Degenerative nuclear changes may also occur if maturation of the transformation zone is arrested; these include pyknosis, referring to condensation of the entire nucleus, and fragmentation or dissolution of chromatin, referred to as karyorrhexis and karyolysis, respectively.
Other epithelial and inflammatory cells in cervical and vaginal smears
Endometrial cells
The appearance of endometrial cells varies with the stage of the cycle and their degree of preservation. During and shortly after menstruation they are grouped in well-formed tight three-dimensional clusters with a peripheral rim of epithelial cells and a central core of stromal cells (Fig. 21.24). Degenerative changes quickly supervene, with crumpling of the nuclei and disorganisation of the cells. These then stand out as small clusters of densely hyperchromatic crowded cells (Fig. 21.25), in contrast to the larger, more regular and better-preserved groups of endocervical cells. Neutrophil polymorphs are often seen within endometrial clusters. Endometrial cells of both epithelial and stromal origin can be very well preserved in liquid-based preparations reflecting prompt fixation at the time of sample taking. Loose aggregates and single histiocytes are often associated with shed endometrial cells and may be confused with severely dyskaryotic cells if their reniform nuclei and delicate cytoplasm are overlooked.
The cellular changes in endometrial cells in cervical smears in pathological states, such as endometrial hyperplasia or neoplasia, are described in Chapter 26.
Reserve cells
Subcolumnar reserve cells are infrequently identified in cervical smears as they do not exfoliate. Possibly they are represented by some of the bare nuclei seen in the vicinity of some endocervical groups. When reactive reserve cell hyperplasia has occurred the cells can sometimes be identified as syncytial groups of small crowded cells with indistinct cell borders and round darkly stained nuclei which often overlap (Fig. 21.26). They may be distinguished from the cell groups of glandular dyskaryosis by the lack of architectural abnormalities, the smaller size and uniform chromatin pattern of their nuclei and by the presence of associated bare nuclei and normal endocervical cells in conventional smears.
Neutrophil polymorphs
These are the commonest of the non-epithelial cells found in normal smears, their presence being physiological within the mucous plug of the cervix. They can be found in large numbers without necessarily implying significant infection, although they are usually increased in cases of cervicitis or vaginitis and also in established malignant disease of the cervix. The clinical context and the overall cytological findings are important in evaluating their significance. There may be problems in the interpretation of a sample if the epithelial cells are largely obscured by polymorphs. This problem is overcome to a considerable extent by the use of liquid-based methods of preparation (see Fig. 21.57).
Macrophages
Macrophages are sometimes seen as part of the inflammatory cell population, especially following menstruation and in postmenopausal women. They are extremely variable in size and appearance, but can generally be distinguished from parabasal or columnar cells by their ill-defined foamy cytoplasm, their eccentric bean-shaped nuclei, and the presence of ingested particulate material in some instances. However, many of them have small round central nuclei and do not contain phagocytosed particles, making identification less certain. It is helpful when in doubt to examine neighbouring cells as these frequently include other macrophages with more typical features (Fig. 21.27).
Macrophages, although usually dissociated cells, may be loosely aggregated especially in postmenstrual smears. They may become multinucleated and very large, forming giant cells, a phenomenon most often seen in postmenopausal women (Fig. 21.28).
Lymphocytes
These cells are usually scanty, forming a minor component of the inflammatory cell population in some normal women. They are present in larger numbers in follicular cervicitis, in association with tingible-body macrophages (see Fig. 21.67).
Cells other than inflammatory and epithelial cells
Spermatozoa
Spermatozoa are seen in postcoital smears, even several days after intercourse (Fig. 21.29).
Contaminants
Cytological specimens can be contaminated at any stage in the collection, transmission or laboratory preparation of the sample. Liquid-based cytology preparations are less prone to contamination from these sources. In addition, cervical samples may include extraneous material from the vagina or vulva, even including parasites or their ova from the digestive tract, especially in those parts of the world where parasitic infestations are common.3 Even outside such endemic areas parasites are encountered from time to time in cervical smears and their identification is important in patient management.
Ova of the threadworm Enterobius vermicularis4 (Fig. 21.30) are not infrequently seen in smears from infected patients, especially if there is poor personal hygiene. The eggs are oval and are smaller than schistosome ova, with a smooth double-walled shell, often with one side flipped over. The larva can usually be recognised within. Occasionally adult forms can be identified (Fig. 21.31).
Fig. 21.30 Ova of Enterobius vermicularis, showing the thick glassy eosinophilic capsule and larva within.
Descriptions of Ascaris lumbricoides, Taenia coli,5 Trichuris trichura, Hymenolepis nana6 and the microfilaria of Wuchereria bancrofti7,8 have been recorded. Schistosoma haematobium, S. japonicum and S. mansoni ova can be identified in smears as elliptical ova, larger than those of the threadworm E. vermicularis. The first two are the common types of schistosome ova found in cervical smears and are distinguished by the presence of either a terminal or lateral spine, respectively (Fig. 21.32).9 The trophozoites of Balantidium coli may be seen in patients with intestinal infestation by this uncommon protozoal organism (Fig. 21.33).
Pediculus humanus, the body louse, and the pubic louse, Phthirus pubis, are seen occasionally in cervical smears (Fig. 21.34). The louse may be damaged during smear preparation, with fragmentation of the tail part from head and legs.
Many external contaminants have been described, including pollen and insects due to atmospheric contamination, and also various fungi, either from contaminated laboratory solutions, the water supply or from the atmosphere (Fig. 21.35). Particulate material from sources such as tampons or glove powder is usually easily identified (Fig. 21.36).10
A refractile brown deposit overlying the central portion of the cytoplasm, known as ‘cornflake artefact’, may be seen in samples – particularly on direct smears and may obscure nuclear detail (Fig. 21.37). This is thought to result from the trapping of air on the surface of cells during mounting, especially in thickly spread direct smears. Inadequate removal of spray fixative containing Carbowax may cause similar problems. The artefact may be so marked as to require a further sample for accurate assessment.
Lubricant contamination may occasionally be seen with some liquid-based cytology preparations. The morphological appearances are variable and include amorphous blue deposits and stringy eosinophilic background material.11
Carryover of cellular material from one sample to another may occur during sample preparation, including staining, posing difficulty in assessing the findings. The contaminant cells are often distributed along the upper or side edge of the slide in direct smears and may be in a slightly different plane of focus from the rest of the cells. If there is any abnormality in the carryover it is confined to cells at this site and does not appear to relate to the morphology of other cells present.
Assessment of quality of smears
The question of adequacy of cervical samples is central to the success of cervical screening in the prevention of cervical cancer death (see Chs 22–24). The problem of establishing exactly what constitutes an adequate sample has received increasing attention in recent years, culminating in broad guidelines from various sources, including the British Society for Clinical Cytology (BSCC), which has issued criteria for acceptability of smear quality12 (currently on direct conventional smears only). In North America, the Bethesda system (TBS) of terminology advocates a minimum threshold for sample adequacy.13 While there is by no means unanimity over these criteria, it is important that cytologists have a degree of confidence about the threshold of acceptability of sample quality.
The feature of paramount importance in assessing sample quality is that there should be adequate numbers of epithelial cells on the slide, with evidence that they are from the appropriate area of the cervix (Fig. 21.38). In theory, the latter requirement can only be satisfied if squamous metaplastic cells, endocervical cells and mucus are present to indicate transformation zone origin and if the sample taker has visualised the cervix and sampled the entire circumference of the transformation zone at the external os.14 Clearly, however, metaplastic cells will not be firmly identifiable once the transformation zone is fully mature, and endocervical cells will not always be sampled, especially after the menopause. Recognition of a representative sample therefore requires knowledge of the woman’s age and menstrual status and of any hormonal treatment.
Formal training in cervical sample taking is essential if the test is to be reliable and such training is increasingly available. As a quality assurance measure, the proportion of inadequate or unsatisfactory cervical samples in relation to the entire sample workload of a laboratory provides a valuable indication of the standard of reporting and of the level of expertise of the sample takers. The National Health Service Cervical Screening Programme (NHSCSP) has set up a system in England and Wales monitoring laboratory reporting against national targets to ensure that laboratories fall within acceptable ranges for all reporting categories.12
In the UK, to reduce the possibility of incorrect assessment by the laboratory, quality control screening procedures are mandatory for all negative and inadequate samples prior to report authorisation. These samples must be read by two independent screeners – one of whom will perform a full in-depth screen with overlapping fields of view and covering the entire sample. The second screener will perform a more rapid assessment of the sample. This may occur after the initial full-screening – so-called ‘rapid review’ or prior to the full-screen: ‘rapid pre-view’. These abbreviated quality assurance screening methods have been found to detect abnormalities missed on initial primary screening.15–17
Criteria for assessing smear quality
Liquid-based cytology samples
Liquid-based thin layer cytological preparations (LBC), usually collected by brush sampling, reduce the rate of obscured and inadequate samples by removing much of the inflammatory debris and blood and providing a representative sample of all of the material from the spatula, most of which is usually discarded in routine smear preparation. Since 2008, the entire UK NHSCSP has adopted LBC preparations. The Bethesda System in America has adopted 5000 cells per sample as a minimum threshold for adequacy.13 With its 3–5 yearly routine screening interval, the UK NHSCSP’s more stringent criteria are considered more appropriate than those adopted by TBS, but none have yet been agreed nationally, and sample adequacy is the subject of a Health Technology Assessments (HTA) study which has yet to report (see Ch. 22).
Influence of sex hormones on squamous epithelium
The diagnostic potential of cytohormonal evaluation using vaginal smears was reported as early as 1925 by Papanicolaou.24 Hormonal cytology is a bioassay, which means that it is not a measurement of the concentration of circulating hormone; rather it is the effect of the hormone on the target organ, in this case the stratified squamous epithelium, that is evaluated and this may reflect the combined effect of several hormones. The ratio of superficial cells with pyknotic nuclei to less mature cells with vesicular nuclei was estimated at intervals, giving a karyopyknotic index (KPI). Other indices included counting cells with eosinophilic cytoplasm, so providing an eosinophilic index (EI). Such techniques have now been replaced by direct measurement of serum hormone levels.
Oestrogens
Oestrogens promote growth and maturation of stratified squamous epithelium up to and including the superficial layer. Smears contain many superficial epithelial cells when the oestrogen level is high and unopposed by progesterone, as in the first half of the menstrual cycle. These cells lie quite flat and are generally discrete; the smear background is noticeably free of polymorphs (Fig. 21.41B).
Progesterone
Many Döderlein’s bacilli (lactobacilli) and leucocytes appear in the smear. They bring about cytolysis of the intermediate cells, causing dissolution of the cell cytoplasm (Fig. 21.43). As a result, numerous naked vesicular nuclei are present and the smear may appear hypocellular. Further progesterone induces the appearance of boat-shaped navicular cells (Fig. 21.44).
When there is mild oestrogen deficiency, as may be encountered at the time of the menopause, the cytological pattern is difficult to distinguish from that of progesterone or androgen stimulation. The clusters are, however, usually slightly smaller, often containing no more than 10 cells.
Androgen
Administration of this hormone when the stratified squamous epithelium is atrophic and smears are composed exclusively of parabasal cells results in a predominance of intermediate cells (Fig. 21.45). The smears are particularly rich in cells.25 If androgens are administered to patients with fully mature stratified squamous epithelium, the opposite effect is seen: superficial cells disappear, to be replaced by intermediate cells. Prolonged administration of androgens produces a smear pattern with cytolysis.
Physiological cytohormonal patterns
Sexual maturity
When menstrual cycles become ovulatory, the following consecutive patterns can be expected (see Fig. 21.46):
Pregnancy
In the event of pregnancy, the corpus luteum does not involute but instead grows larger, producing increasing amounts of progesterone and oestrogen. The cytological pattern of pregnancy is that of heightened progesterone activity, with clustering and folding of intermediate cells and the presence of navicular cells. These boat-shaped cells are distended with yellow glycogen, having a rim of folded cytoplasm and the nucleus pushed to the periphery (Fig. 21.44). The changes are most pronounced in the third trimester, when numerous lactobacilli are seen and the accompanying cytolysis is at its height.
About 3 months after conception, the placenta takes over the task of producing progesterone and oestrogens from the corpus luteum. Arias-Stella changes, seen in the endometrium in some pregnancies, may also develop in endocervical glands and have been described as a rare finding in cervical or vaginal smears.26,27 The cells have an exaggerated secretory pattern as seen in the endometrial glands, and show enlarged degenerate hyperchromatic nuclei with intranuclear inclusions. The association with pregnancy and lack of any preserved abnormal chromatin pattern, combined with awareness of this entity, should ensure correct assessment of the findings.
Cytotrophoblastic cells also cover the villi. They are cuboidal cells with central nuclei. Cytologically, these cells cannot be firmly identified and may mimic neoplastic cells due to their prominent nucleoli, coarse chromatin pattern and high N:C ratio (Fig. 21.47).
Intact placental villi have occasionally been identified in samples taken postpartum28 As illustrated in Figure 21.48, a villus may be recognised by its size and form, with degenerate trophoblastic cells and inflammatory debris coating a long three-dimensional structure which has a translucent quality internally.
Decidual cells are modified endometrial stromal cells responding to the high circulating progesterone levels in pregnancy or to high progesterone content oral contraceptives. Decidual changes may also occur in the stromal cells of the cervix and are occasionally sampled in smears taken during or shortly after pregnancy. The cells are swollen and pale due to their content of glycogen. They have abundant clear, sometimes vacuolated cytoplasm and central large nuclei. The chromatin is often smudged and ill-defined and nucleoli are prominent. Decidual cells can be recognised by the fact that, in contrast to squamous epithelial cells, they are not flat but convex; the cells are round to oval and the cytoplasm appears to be less dense than that of epithelial cells (Fig. 21.49).29