Organ
One-year survival (%)
Five-year survival (%)
Kidney (DBD)
96
89
Kidney (DCD)
95
88
Kidney (living)
99
95
Liver
93
80
SPK
96
90
Lung
82
55
Heart
81
78
Table 25.2
Transplant terminology
Transplant terminology | Definition |
---|---|
Autologous transplant | A transplanted graft occurring on the same individual (e.g. autologous skin graft) |
Syngeneic transplant | A graft transplanted from one genetically identical individual to another (i.e. identical twins) |
Allogeneic transplant | An allograft is transplanted from one genetically dissimilar individual to another (i.e. different HLA genes) |
Xenogeneic transplant | A xenograft is transplanted between individuals of a different species |
Orthotopic transplant | Graft inserted into normal anatomical location |
Heterotopic transplant | Graft inserted into a different anatomical site |
Antigen | Any substances that stimulates antibody production by the immune system |
Table 25.3
Pros and cons of working in transplant surgery
Pros | Cons |
---|---|
Technically challenging | On-call commitments and unsociable hours |
Intellectually stimulating | Long surgeries |
Life-saving operations | Little or no private practice |
Practice of critical care | Emotionally demanding |
Patient Fitness
Assessing patient suitability for transplantation is a multi-disciplinary process, involving the whole transplantation team (surgeons, physicians, transplant coordinators, pathologists, anaesthetists, specialist nurses, psychologists, etc). This review process aims to balance the risks and potential benefits for the individual patient, as well as ensuring optimal utilisation of a limited resource. Deciding who needs a transplant is difficult. Key questions for the transplant unit include:
- 1.
Is the patient in definite need of transplantation?
- 2.
Is the patient physically and mentally fit enough to undergo the procedure?
- 3.
Is transplantation likely to be of overall benefit of the patient?
Donor Organs
One major challenge to organ transplantation is the availability of suitable donor organs. Despite donor numbers increasing, there remains a shortage and 456 people died in the UK waiting for an organ in 2013/14 [9].
Donor organs can be cadaveric or from living donors.
Donation after brainstem death (DBD): patients have suffered irretrievable neurological injury and have been certified dead following formal brainstem death testing. Cardio-respiratory function and end-organ perfusion is maintained after death through ventilation on a critical care unit.
Donation after circulatory death (DCD): retrieval commences shortly after cessation of cardio-respiratory function, following withdrawal of treatment from patients for whom ongoing treatment is discussed and agreed to be futile. DCD is also known as ‘Non-heart beating donation.’
Living donation: this is becoming an increasingly common donating option, particularly for kidney transplants but also in liver transplantation. In the former one of the donor’s two kidneys is retrieved and implanted into the recipient, whereas in the latter only a portion of healthy liver is removed from a living donor.
Transplant Immunology and Organ Rejection
Donated organs are often ‘matched’ with the recipient before transplantation occurs. But what does this mean?
Allogeneic tissues are recognised as ‘foreign’ by the recipient immune system: antigens of the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC)/Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) which are present on donor cell surfaces will differ (i.e. be foreign) to the recipient’s.
Class I HLA antigens are found on all nucleated cells and are divided into HLA-A, HLA-B and HLA-C. Class II HLA antigens are only present on antigen presenting cells, such as macrophages and dendritic cells, and are divided into HLA-DP, HLA-DQ and HLA-DR.
HLA expression is extremely polymorphic throughout the population. Whilst this increases the chances of eradicating infectious agents, tissue matching becomes problematic in the context of organ transplantation.
As a result, various investigations are performed to ensure that the most appropriate organs are transplanted into the most suitable patients.
HLA screening
Potential recipients are screened for anti-HLA antibodies against donor HLA antigens
Cross-matching
Serum from the recipient (which could contain anti-donor antibodies) is mixed with serum from the donor
If recipient antibodies bind/kill donor lymphocytes a positive cross-match is present, which is a contraindication to transplantation due to an increased risk of hyperacute rejection
Ischaemia Reperfusion Injury (IRI)
The action of transplanting an organ initiates an inflammatory response, a process which can lead to organ rejection. Once the donor blood supply is cut off from the organ, tissue ischaemia ensues: hypoxic conditions deplete cells of ATP which leads to cell death and inflammatory mediator release. Although revascularisation is crucial for salvaging the organ, reperfusion itself can cause tissue damage both locally and systemically. So-called ‘marginal’ organs are at a higher risk of IRI, as they are sourced from an extended donor pool. For example, the donor may be elderly or have significant co-morbidities.
Hyperacute Rejection
Hyperacute rejection occurs almost immediately following transplantation resulting in swelling and discoloration of the donor organ, which is catastrophic for the patient. It is due to pre-formed cytotoxic antibodies present in the host, specific for donor antigens. Fortunately, hyperacute rejection is rare owing to careful cross-matching.
Acute Rejection
Acute rejection arises in as many as 50 % of grafts less than six months post-transplant and is characterised by a T-cell response, accompanied by a number of inflammatory mediators such as tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNFα), interferon-gamma (IFNγ) and interleukin-2 (IL-2).
A T-cell-mediated response can only take place if the T-cell has received two signals: signal one occurs at the T-cell receptor interaction with antigen, which is presented by MHC on antigen-presenting cells (APC) (Fig. 25.1). Signal two is provided by co-stimulatory molecules on the APC, which bind to various complimentary molecules on the T-cell surface. If signal one occurs in the absence of signal two T-cell anergy, or unresponsiveness, ensues (i.e. no immune response). However, if co-stimulatory cell-cell interactions occur between the T-cell and the APC (signal two), then a full T-cell response is initiated. This two signal model is significant in the development of new anti-rejection medications (see below).
Fig. 25.1
Two-signal activation of the adaptive immune system. Antigen presenting cells present antigen via MHC molecules, recognised by the T-cell receptor. A co-stimulatory signal is also transmitted, to ensure full activation of the immune system. Several immunosuppressive drugs inhibit the actions of this pathway
Chronic Rejection
Chronic rejection occurs more than six months post-transplant. Contributing features include antibody release by plasma cells that ultimately destroy the graft, and as such is an irreversible process. Usually the result of vascular occlusion, chronic rejection is characterised by antibody responses to vascular endothelial cells and the subsequent response of these cells, such as smooth muscle proliferation and interstitial scarring.
Immunosuppression
To prevent organ rejection, transplant recipients are placed on anti-rejection medication, or immunosuppression. Unfortunately, there are no specific methods to prevent an immune response which is directed only to the grafted organ, meaning a non-specific dampening of the entire immune system is required.
Corticosteroids
Steroids prevent the synthesis of numerous pro-inflammatory mediators in cells of the immune system. Targeting such a generic component brings with it multiple complications including delayed wound healing, increased risk of infection, diabetes mellitus and Cushingoid symptoms. Consequently, steroid therapy is rarely used long-term and as such, steroid-sparing therapy is used.
Calcineurin Inhibitors
T-cells require two signals to become fully activated. Calcineurin inhibitors, such as ciclosporin and tacrolimus, block the propagation of ‘signal one’, preventing IL-2 production, which is the major stimulus for T-cell proliferation.
Anti-metabolites
Anti-metabolites such as azathioprine and mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) block DNA synthesis and therefore prevent T-cell proliferation, avoiding anti-graft immune responses. However, these drugs can cause severe adverse effects due to the non-specific killing of other rapidly dividing cells such as erythrocytes.
Cell Depletion
CAMPATH-1, or alemtuzumab, is a humanised monoclonal antibody specific for the cell surface marker CD52, which is present on all lymphocytes. As such, this is an effective lymphocyte-depleting therapy which prevents organ rejection. This drug is usually administered prior to transplantation, ensuring T-cell depletion.
Co-stimulation Blockade
Cytotoxic T-lymphocyte antigen 4 (CTLA4) is a co-inhibitory molecule that reduces T-cell activation by blocking ‘signal two’. Drugs such as belatacept and abatacept, which boost the activity of CTLA4, have shown clinical efficacy in transplantation (as they prevent overt T-cell activation). The BENEFIT study showed that belatacept was associated with improved GFR and renal graft survival compared with cyclosporine treatment post-transplant [12].
Risks of Immunosuppression
As non-specific immunosuppression compromises the immune system, opportunistic pathogens take advantage. Prophylactic antibiotics can be administered accordingly, depending on the likelihood of the microbe species.
The ten-year incidence of de novo malignancy in transplant recipients is twice that of the general population [5]. Moreover, the risk of non-melanoma skin cancer is thirteen times greater. This phenomenon is due to defective cancer immune-surveillance, which also facilitates oncogenic viruses. Cancers including lymphoma (EBV-associated), melanoma (papillovirus) and Kaposi’s sarcoma (human herpesvirus-8) are common. As such, cancer surveillance is an important aspect of follow-up care.
Kidney Transplantation
Epidemiology
In 2013/14, 3032 kidney transplants took place in the UK while 5881 patients were on the waiting list [9].
Aetiology
Kidney transplants are usually indicated in end-stage renal disease (eGFR < 15 mL/min), with common causes including:
Diabetic kidney disease
Hypertensive kidney disease
Glomerulonephritis
Polycystic kidney disease
Dialysis is offered at this stage but is only a short-term, non-curative solution. Ultimately, patients will require a transplant, which offers the best chance of long-term survival. Most studies demonstrate significantly lower mortality in kidney transplant recipients, compared with haemodialysis patients [11]. In addition, the quality of life of kidney transplant recipients is significantly superior. Absolute contraindications include active infection and malignancy, whereas relative contraindications include patient age and other significant co-morbidities.