10 The hematoxylins and eosin
Eosin
Under certain circumstances eosin staining is intense and difficulty may be experienced in obtaining adequate differentiation; this may occur after mercuric fixation. Over-differentiation of the eosin may be continued until only the red blood cells and granules of eosinophil polymorph are stained red. This is, occasionally, used to facilitate the location and identification of eosinophils. Combining eosin Y and phloxine B (10 ml 1% phloxine B, 100 ml 1% eosin Y, 780 ml 95% alcohol, 4 ml glacial acetic acid) produces a cytoplasmic stain, which more dramatically demonstrates various tissue components. Muscle is clearly differentiated from collagen, and red cells stain bright red. According to Luna (1992), eosin dye content should be 88% and not contain sodium sulfate (sometimes used as filler). When using this dye in solution, a fine granular precipitate forms, and the staining of the cytoplasm will be poor.
Alum hematoxylins
This group comprises most of those that are used routinely in the hematoxylin and eosin stain, and produce good nuclear staining. The mordant is aluminum, usually in the form of ‘potash alum’ (aluminum potassium sulfate) or ‘ammonium alum’ (aluminum ammonium sulfate). All stain the nuclei a red color, which is converted to the familiar blue-black when the section is washed in a weak alkali solution. Tap water is usually alkaline enough to produce this color change, but occasionally alkaline solutions such as saturated lithium carbonate, 0.05% ammonia in distilled water, or Scott’s tap water substitute (see Appendix III) are necessary. This procedure is known as ‘blueing’.
Ehrlich’s hematoxylin (Ehrlich 1886)
This is a naturally ripening alum hematoxylin which takes about 2 months to ripen; the ripening time can be shortened somewhat by placing the unstoppered bottle in a warm sunny place such as a window-ledge, and is shorter in the summer than in winter. Once satisfactorily ripened, this hematoxylin solution will last in bulk for years, and retains its staining ability in a Coplin jar for some months. Ehrlich’s hematoxylin, as well as being an excellent nuclear stain, also stains mucins including the mucopolysaccharides of cartilage; it is recommended for the staining of bone and cartilage (Chapter 16).
Preparation of solution
Hematoxylin | 2 g |
Absolute alcohol | 100 ml |
Glycerin | 100 ml |
Distilled water | 100 ml |
Glacial acetic acid | 10 ml |
Potassium alum | 15 g approx. |
Delafield’s hematoxylin (Delafield 1885)
A naturally ripened alum hematoxylin, Delafield’s has similar longevity to Ehrlich’s hematoxylin.
Preparation of solution
Hematoxylin | 4 g |
95% alcohol | 125 ml |
Saturated aqueous ammonium alum (15 g/100 ml) | 400 ml |
Glycerin | 100 ml |
Mayer’s hematoxylin (Mayer 1903)
Preparation of solution
Hematoxylin | 1 g |
Distilled water | 1000 ml |
Potassium or ammonium alum | 50 g |
Sodium iodate | 0.2 g |
Citric acid | 1 g |
Chloral hydrate SLR | 50 g or |
Chloral hydrate AR | 30 g |
Harris’s hematoxylin (Harris 1900)
This alum hematoxylin was traditionally chemically ripened with mercuric oxide. As mercuric oxide is highly toxic, environmentally unfriendly, and has detrimental and corrosive long-term effects on some automated staining machines, sodium or potassium iodate is frequently used as a substitute for oxidation. Harris is a useful general-purpose hematoxylin and gives particularly clear nuclear staining, and for this reason has been used, as a progressive stain, in diagnostic exfoliative cytology. In routine histological practice, it is generally used regressively, but can be useful when used progressively. When using Harris’s hematoxylin as a progressive stain, an acetic acid-alcohol rinse provides a more controllable method in removing excess stain from tissue components and the glass slide. The traditional hydrochloric acid-alcohol acts quickly and indiscriminately, is more difficult to control, and can result in a light nuclear stain. A 5–10% solution of acetic acid, in 70–95% alcohol, detaches dye molecules from the cytoplasm/nucleoplasm while keeping nucleic acid complexes intact (Feldman & Dapson 1985).
Preparation of solution
Hematoxylin | 2.5 g |
Absolute alcohol | 25 ml |
Potassium alum | 50 g |
Distilled water | 500 ml |
Mercuric oxide | 1.25 g or |
Sodium iodate | 0.5 g |
Glacial acetic acid | 20 ml |
Cole’s hematoxylin (Cole 1943)
This is an alum hematoxylin, artificially ripened with an alcoholic iodine solution.
Preparation of solution
Hematoxylin | 1.5 g |
Saturated aqueous potassium alum | 700 ml |
1% iodine in 95% alcohol | 50 ml |
Distilled water | 250 ml |
Carazzi’s hematoxylin (Carazzi 1911)
Carazzi’s is an alum hematoxylin which is chemically ripened using potassium iodate.
Preparation of solution | |
Hematoxylin | 5 g |
Glycerol | 100 ml |
Potassium alum | 25 g |
Distilled water | 400 ml |
Potassium iodate | 0.1 g |
Gill’s hematoxylin (Gill et al. 1974 modified)
Preparation of solution
Hematoxylin | 2 g |
Sodium iodate | 0.2 g |
Aluminum sulfate | 17.6 g |
Distilled water | 750 ml |
Ethylene glycol (ethandiol) | 250 ml |
Glacial acetic acid | 20 ml |
The distilled water and ethylene glycol are mixed, and then the hematoxylin is added and dissolved. The ethylene glycol is an excellent solvent for hematoxylin and it prevents the formation of surface precipitates (Carson 1997). Sodium iodate is added for oxidation, and the aluminum sulfate mordant is then added and dissolved. Finally, the glacial acetic acid is added and stirred for 1 hour. The solution is filtered before use. Carson reported that, although the stain can be used immediately, it provides a better intensity if allowed to ripen for 1 week in a 37°C incubator. It should be noted that the popularity of Gill’s solution has made it one of the more commercially successful formulas.
Double or triple hematoxylin concentrations may be used as preferred. These are usually referred to as Gill’s I (normal), Gill’s II (double), and Gill’s III (triple), with the Gill III being the most concentrated. Gill’s hematoxylin is more frequently used for routine H&E staining than Mayer’s hematoxylin, and is more stable than Harris’s hematoxylin, as auto-oxidation is inhibited to the extent that no measurable changes occur over many months. Disadvantages associated with Gill’s hematoxylin include staining of gelatin adhesive and even the glass itself. Some mucus may also stain darkly, as compared to Harris’s, where mucus generally remains unstained, and the glass usually fails to attract the stain. Feldman and Dapson (1987) theorized that the aluminum sulfate mordant is responsible. Certain charged sites in the tissue, in the adhesive, and on the glass are masked by the Harris mordant, leaving them unavailable for staining. Gill’s mordant system fails to do that, and the sites attract the dye-mordant complex.
Staining times with alum hematoxylins
1. Type of hematoxylin used, e.g. Ehrlich’s 20–45 minutes, Mayer’s 10–20 minutes.
2. Age of stain. As the stain ages, the staining time will need to be increased.
3. Intensity of use of stain. A heavily used hematoxylin will lose its staining powers more rapidly and longer staining times will be necessary.
4. Whether the stain is used progressively or regressively, e.g. Mayer’s hematoxylin used progressively 5–10 minutes, used regressively 10–20 minutes.
5. Pre-treatment of tissues or sections, e.g. length of time in fixative or acid decalcifying solution, or whether paraffin or frozen sections.
6. Post-treatment of sections, e.g. subsequent acid stains such as van Gieson.