CHAPTER 5 Salivary glands
Chapter contents
Introduction
There is perhaps no tissue anywhere in the body that is subject to such a diverse and heterogeneous range of tumours and tumour-like conditions. While this results in fascinating cytopathology it also imposes limitations, which must be appreciated by both pathologists and clinicians if the extensive benefits of cytodiagnosis are to be fully and safely utilised in patient management. In recent years, advances in imaging techniques have contributed much to the assessment of salivary gland disease, but the findings are not uncommonly equivocal. Clinical management of salivary gland masses is increasingly relying on pre-treatment diagnosis derived from microscopic examination. Preoperative histological biopsy using a Vim-Silverman or Tru-Cut needle, or intraoperative frozen sections have their own hazards and organisational problems. In contrast, fine needle aspiration (FNA) is virtually risk free and offers enough information to plan appropriate patient management. This chapter discusses the cytological findings in commonly encountered salivary gland conditions along with diagnostic pitfalls and limitations. We hope that the algorithm provided at the end will be a useful guide in assessing salivary gland cytology.
Aspiration technique
Standard fine needle aspiration (FNA) technique, using the capillary method without suction and direct spreading onto glass slides is the preference of the authors and is applicable to major and minor salivary glands.1 The non-suction technique is advocated in order to avoid the post-FNA changes found in some lesions on histological examination after excision.1 Alternatively, FNA samples may be rinsed in a solution and prepared either as cytospin preparations or as liquid based cytology (LBC). Immunosuppressed patients are prone to salivary gland disease and care should be taken to avoid needlestick injuries.2 Cystic masses are best aspirated using a syringe attached to the needle, with or without a syringe holder. If possible, any residual mass should be re-aspirated in order to obtain representative cellular material. If microbiological culture or other ancillary investigations are required, repeat aspiration for this purpose is advised, as division of a single aspirate is seldom satisfactory. A combined approach of ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration of head and neck masses, with immediate assessment of the material by a pathologist, can be more accurate than are specimens obtained in other ways.3
Normal salivary gland components
Acinar and ductal epithelium
Acinar cells are large, with abundant cytoplasm and small round uniform nuclei. The cytoplasm is finely granular in serous glands and clear or lightly vacuolated in mucous glands. Either type is fragile and easily disrupted by smearing, so that dispersed bare nuclei are found in the background. When complete acini are aspirated, the cells occur in compact lobulated groups (Fig. 5.1).
Intraparotid lymph nodes
Clinically, a frequently encountered problem is the distinction between enlarged lymph nodes and sialomegaly, particularly in the case of the parotid glands. Due to late encapsulation in foetal life, small lymph nodes are commonly enclosed within the parotid. It is not possible to distinguish between intraparotid lymphadenopathy and true salivary gland pathology reliably by palpation or imaging. FNA of a hyperplastic lymph node yields a mixed population of lymphocytes, follicle centre cells and ‘tingible body’ macrophages. When perinodal salivary tissue is also sampled, it becomes difficult to separate lymphadenopathy from salivary gland disease associated with lymphocytosis.
Ectopic salivary glands
Ectopic (heterotopic) salivary gland tissue is commonly found in periparotid lymph nodes, middle ear and lower neck, but can also occur in more remote regions. Either normal acinar cells or material indicating benign or malignant disease can be encountered, as any of the salivary gland disorders found in normally placed salivary gland tissue can develop.4,5
Non-neoplastic conditions
Cysts
A systematic approach to the diagnosis of cystic salivary gland lesions by FNA can result in a correct diagnosis in >70% of cases.6 Careful attention should be directed at identifying the extracellular fluid component (mucoid versus watery proteinaceous) as well as the predominant cellular component (e.g. lymphocytes, histiocytes, epithelial cells and oncocytes). Occasionally, epithelial cells may not be obtained on FNA of cystic salivary gland lesions.
Mucus cyst (mucocele)
Cytological findings: mucocele
The fluid is watery or viscous depending upon whether the epithelium is predominantly serous or mucinous (Fig. 5.2). It is relatively hypocellular, containing only a few leucocytes and macrophages and perhaps occasional sheets of columnar cells. Occasionally, leucocytosis is pronounced and the epithelial cells display reactive and inflammatory atypia. Collagenous spherulosis within a mucocele has been described.7
Diagnostic pitfalls: mucocele
Cystic change occurs in both benign (Warthin’s tumour, pleomorphic adenoma) and malignant (mucoepidermoid carcinoma, acinic cell carcinoma, high-grade carcinoma) salivary gland tumours.8 Low-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma cannot be excluded in aspirates diagnosed as mucinous cystic lesions.6
Lymphoepithelial cyst
Bilateral and multiple lymphoepithelial cysts (LECs) of major salivary glands, in particular of parotid glands, are uncommon but are reported in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infected patients with an incidence of about 3–6% (Fig. 5.3). They represent an early manifestation of HIV infection and are rarely found in patients with advanced disease. They are the most common presentation (58.9%) of HIV infection in children.9
Branchial cleft cyst
Branchial cysts are usually asymptomatic but one-third present acutely due to inflammation (Fig. 5.4). Aspirates yield abundant or scanty viscous fluid, which contains mature squamous cells and keratinous debris. Although lymphoid tissue is present in its wall, aspirates are usually taken from the centre of the lesion and therefore almost never contain lymphoid cells. Macrophages, cholesterol crystals and acute inflammatory cells are found in cysts where the epithelial lining has been disrupted. With associated inflammation, the squamous epithelial cells often exhibit mild nuclear atypia. In such cases, differentiation of a branchial cyst from cystic metastasis of a squamous cell carcinoma from upper aerodigestive tract and occasionally lungs becomes important. Examination of alcohol-fixed smears with better presentation of keratin and nuclear detail, and careful scrutiny for immature cells, dyskaryotic nuclei, pleomorphism and necrosis, should clarify the distinction in most cases. Well-differentiated squamous cell carcinoma metastasis with only mild nuclear abnormalities can be difficult to exclude and in such a case, radiological imaging and panendoscopy with biopsies should be recommended. Branchial cysts usually present before the age of 40 but so can some squamous carcinoma; age alone is not a reliable discriminator.
Sialadenitis
Acute sialadenitis
Acute sialadenitis is due to specific bacterial or viral infection such as mumps parotitis. It is usually clinically obvious and FNA is not indicated. CMV sialadenitis should be considered in the differential diagnosis of painless salivary gland enlargement in patients with AIDS.13 The presence of acute inflammatory cells in a salivary gland FNA does not always indicate acute sialadenitis; some salivary gland tumours may contain acute inflammation, either due to necrosis or as a result of a previous FNA. Such aspirates should be carefully assessed for other pathology that may be obscured by inflammation.
Chronic sialadenitis
Chronic sclerosing sialadenitis (CSS), also known as Kuttner tumour, is a cryptogenic tumour-like condition of the salivary glands. Immune-mediated processes are suspected in its pathogenesis and CSS is occasionally reported to be associated with sclerosing pancreatitis.14
Cytological findings: chronic sialadenitis
Aspirates are generally hypocellular and epithelial cells, when present, are of ductal type. Acinar cells are unusual due to the atrophic changes (Fig. 5.5). Occasionally, large numbers of non-birefringent crystalloids (deep blue with May–Grünwald–Giemsa (MGG) or Diff-Quik and bright orange with Papanicolaou stain) of varying sizes and shapes are present. Lymphocytes, plasma cells, multinucleated histiocytes and neutrophils are also seen.15,16
Granulomatous sialadenitis
Granulomatous involvement of salivary glands is present in about 6% of cases of sarcoidosis. Clusters of epithelioid cells, multinucleated histiocytes and lymphoid cells are seen in aspirates (Fig. 5.6). Duct obstruction with salivary leakage can incite a granulomatous reaction. Other causes include tuberculosis, fungal infection, cat scratch disease, brucellosis and toxoplas-mosis. Granulomatous reaction to non-tyrosine crystalloids can be associated with both neoplastic and non-neoplastic salivary gland disease, and they may be a product of oncocytic cell secretion.17
Myoepithelial sialadenitis
Myoepithelial sialadenitis (MESA) is commonest in middle-aged or elderly women and is usually bilateral and symmetrical, although sometimes initially unilateral. In cases of Sjögren’s syndrome, other manifestations such as dryness of eyes and mouth, rheumatoid arthritis and hypergammaglobulinaemia are present.
Cytological findings: MESA
FNA preparations contain numerous lymphocytes mixed with follicle centre cells, plasma cells and histiocytes (Fig. 5.7). Clusters of myoepithelial cells, if present, are a helpful pointer to the disease but are not always evident in aspirates. Florid lymphocytosis is seen in other conditions, including chronic sialadenitis, Warthin’s tumour, mucoepidermoid carcinoma, acinic cell carcinoma and non-Hodgkin lymphoma.18,19 Aspiration of perisalivary lymph nodes is another source of lymphoid tissue. Benign lymphoepithelial lesion can progress to malignant lymphoma; while high-grade lymphoma is easier to recognise, morphological differentiation from low-grade lymphoma can be difficult. Correlation with clinical findings and use of ancillary methods (flow cytometry, gene rearrangement studies) can help arrive at the diagnosis. FNA of lymphoid lesions with ancillary aids can make a definitive diagnosis.20 The diagnosis of benign lymphoepithelial lesion is best established by correlating the clinical and cytopathological findings and using ancillary methods such as flow cytometry and gene rearrangement studies.21,22
Miscellaneous conditions
Sialadenosis
This is a non-inflammatory, often bilateral, swelling of the salivary glands, particularly of the parotid caused by hypertrophy of the acinar cells. It is associated with hormonal, nutritional or neurogenic disorders and with systemic diseases such as diabetes.23
Sclerosing polycystic adenosis
Sclerosing polycystic adenosis is a recently described, rare lesion of the salivary gland. It can simulate a slow growing tumour. It is pseudoencapsulated and includes tubuloacinar adenosis with dilated ducts, apocrine metaplasia, epithelial hyperplasia and cystic changes associated with fibrosis, histologically resembling fibrocystic disease of the breast.24 Recognition of this benign entity is important since the differential diagnosis includes other more common benign and malignant salivary gland neoplasms, particularly mucoepidermoid carcinoma and tumours with cystic and oncocytic features. The aspirates are characterised by flat cohesive sheets of epithelial cells with moderate amounts of finely granular oncocytic cytoplasm and enlarged round nuclei with indistinct nucleoli. Some epithelial groups form glandular structures with lumens, and the background contains small amounts of delicate mucoproteinaceous material. Occasional markedly vacuolated cells may be present, as well as many cells with apocrine change manifested by well-defined apical snouting.25,26
Adenomatoid hyperplasia
Adenomatous ductal hyperplasia (ADH) of the salivary glands is rare, occurring almost exclusively in the palate. It is characterised histologically by the proliferating ducts which resemble intercalated duct epithelium. ADH is compared with adenomatoid acinar hyperplasia (AAH), a lesion found predominantly in intraoral salivary glands and histologically composed of hyperplastic acinar cells. The nature of these lesions is not clear. However, ADH may be a precursor lesion of salivary gland tumours (especially epithelial-myoepithelial carcinomas), whereas AAH may represent a reactive process of idiopathic nature. Clinically, it is generally misdiagnosed as a neoplasm.27–29 It is a potential source of a false positive diagnosis of mucoepidermoid carcinoma.
Lipomatosis
The parotid and, to a lesser extent, the submandibular gland normally contain adipose tissue, which increases with advancing age. Lipomatosis is diffuse excess of interstitial fat, which may occur in obesity and diabetes and occasionally presents as a swelling. Fatty replacement of atrophic parenchyma, sialolipoma, periparotid lipomata and sialometaplasia in pleomorphic adenoma are other causes of fat cells in an aspirate.30–35
Oncocytosis
Focal oncocytic change is common with increasing age. In diffuse hyperplastic oncocytosis of the parotid gland, extensive metaplasia of acinic and ductal cells leads to transformation of nearly all cells into oncocytes.36 Cytologically, oncocytosis may be difficult to distinguish from oncocytoma or paucilymphocytic Warthin’s tumour. Areas of oncocytic differentiation can occur in pleomorphic adenoma.
Tumours of the salivary gland
Salivary gland tumours are uncommon. The annual incidence around the world is between 0.4 and 13.5 cases per 100 000 population, of which benign tumours represent between 54% and 79%. The majority of primary epithelial tumours occur in the parotid (up to 80%), followed by minor salivary glands, submandibular gland and sublingual gland. The relative incidence of malignancy is much higher in minor than in major salivary glands. The most recent WHO classification of salivary gland tumours is given in Box 5.1.37
Benign salivary gland neoplasms
Pleomorphic adenoma
Pleomorphic adenoma (mixed tumour) is the commonest salivary gland neoplasm, accounting for 60% of all tumours. Most (80%) occur in the parotid and besides salivary glands, it is occasionally encountered in the nasal cavity, paranasal sinuses, upper respiratory tract and gastrointestinal tract.37 The tumour occurs most often in patients aged 30–50 years and is slightly more common in females. Bilateral synchronous pleomorphic adenomas occur infrequently.38 Histologically, the typical tumour consists of glandular structures composed of a double layer of epithelial and myoepithelial cells embedded in myxoid stroma. Cytology demonstrates most of the histological features of pleomorphic adenoma of salivary gland and is a useful tool in initial assessment of the tumour.39 Squamous metaplasia, oncocytosis, mucus production, sebaceous or adipocytic differentiation30–35 may occur and the mesenchymal component can undergo chondroid metaplasia or even ossification. Collagenous crystalloids may be a clue to the diagnosis of pleomorphic adenoma.40 Cystic change in some tumours presents a diagnostic pitfall both in imaging and cytology.41 Although a benign tumour, there are rare reports, in which these histologically benign tumours have inexplicably metastasised to distant sites.42,43
Cytological findings: pleomorphic adenoma
The cytological diagnosis of the great majority of pleomorphic adenomas is quite straightforward (Fig. 5.8). Aspirates contain plentiful myoepithelial cells, which are closely intermingled with fibrillary myxoid background substance. They lie singly or in sheets and have round to oval nuclei of uniform chromasia, although they may vary a little in size. A characteristic feature is the well-defined cytoplasmic membrane in the majority of these cells and bare nuclei are sparse. The background stromal substance is closely tangled with cells and stains pinkish-grey with Papanicolaou and bright magenta with MGG due to metachromasia. Chondroid change is indicated by a blue reaction with the latter technique. The presence of abundant fibrillary matrix material with single myoepithelial cells in the background is highly diagnostic of pleomorphic adenoma. Published studies based on these criteria confirm a high level of accuracy for FNA diagnosis of pleomorphic adenoma.
Diagnostic pitfalls: pleomorphic adenoma
The histological heterogeneity of pleomorphic adenoma is reflected in its cytology. Problems in interpretation occur for two reasons: the predominance of one element over other components, or the presence of atypical cytomorphological features. If myoepithelial cells are numerous and mesenchymal material not readily apparent, the tumour may be classified as myoepithelioma. Clinically, this is of little significance. If the myxoid component is abundant, it may overwhelm the few epithelial cells present and the lesion may be mistaken for a retention cyst, nodular fasciitis,44 schwannoma or intravenous pyogenic granuloma.46 This is more likely to happen if only MGG-stained slides are examined, as strong metachromasia may mask other cellular components.
More serious is false suspicion of malignancy.47 Some examples of pleomorphic adenoma are highly cellular and display marked cytological atypia. This is reflected in FNA specimens in which the myoepithelial cells can show loss of cohesion, nuclear enlargement and hyperchromasia to a worrying degree. It is important not to overdiagnose these changes. On histological examination, most such ‘atypical’ lesions are pleomorphic adenomas with mild cytological atypia within myoepithelial cells, which is acceptable in the spectrum of benign pleomorphic adenoma. If unequivocal cytological features of malignancy are present, the diagnosis of carcinoma ex-pleomorphic adenoma should be considered (see Carcinoma ex-pleomorphic adenoma, p. 245).
Some pleomorphic adenomas contain adenoid cystic-like areas.48 Globules of basement membrane material may be seen in pleomorphic adenoma and basal cell adenoma, risking a misdiagnosis of adenoid cystic carcinoma, which could result in radical surgery.49 Great caution must be exercised not to confuse the globules in pleomorphic adenoma with true adenoid cystic carcinoma. If the globules are few and other cellular features of pleomorphic adenoma are present, false suspicion of malignancy should not be raised. The seemingly naked nuclei of neoplastic cells in adenoid cystic carcinoma with their coarse nuclear chromatin and irregular nucleoli can reliably distinguish adenoid cystic carcinoma from cylindromatous adenomas50 (see Adenoid cystic carcinoma, p. 243). Occasionally, pleomorphic adenoma may exhibit marked cystic change.36,41,51
Mucin production by pleomorphic adenomas is another difficulty and the differential diagnosis then includes Warthin’s tumour and low-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma. Pleomorphic adenoma occasionally reveals focal squamous metaplasia. When extensive, it may be misdiagnosed as metastatic well-differentiated squamous cell carcinoma or mucoepidermoid carcinoma in FNA.52 Squamous cells can occur in other non-neoplastic and neoplastic lesions of the salivary such as chronic sialadenitis, lymphoepithelial cyst, Warthin’s tumour, and squamous cell carcinoma.53 The presence of squamous, mucinous, and/or sebaceous metaplasia, especially in the absence of chondromyxoid stroma, presents the potential for misinterpretation of the FNA as indicative of malignancy.34,54
Familiarity with the variable aspirate appearance of PA in addition to well-defined cytological and architectural criteria can help establish the proper diagnosis in the majority of cases.55 There remain, however, few cases in which a definitive diagnosis is not possible.56 Small tissue biopsies will not resolve these problems.55
Myoepithelioma
Myoepithelioma (myoepithelial adenoma) is defined as a benign tumour composed almost exclusively of cells showing myoepithelial differentiation. They can be spindle celled, plasmacytoid, epithelioid or clear cell in morphology (Fig. 5.9).37 Many authorities would accept a minor epithelial subpopulation, usually less than 5% tumour volume, within this definition.57 The surrounding stroma can be collagenous or mucoid. About 40% occur in the parotid followed by the minor salivary glands, especially the palate.37
Cytological findings: myoepithelioma
Diagnostic pitfalls: myoepithelioma
Myoepitheliomas are rarely diagnosed correctly on FNA. They are usually described as cellular pleomorphic adenomas, or benign spindle cell tumours depending on the predominant cell type. With experience the cytomorphological features of myoepithelioma are recognisable in FNA material.57–63
Basal cell adenoma
Basal cell adenoma (BCA) is a rare benign epithelial tumour of the salivary gland. BCA is seen most frequently in the parotid gland and less commonly in the submandibular gland and minor glands of the upper lips, oral cavity and hard palate.64
Cytological findings: basal cell adenoma
Diagnostic pitfalls: basal cell adenoma
The potential of mistaking basal cell adenoma for adenoid cystic carcinoma is evident from the above description and must be kept in mind. Hyaline globules are smaller and fewer than those seen in adenoid cystic carcinoma and critical examination of the shape and intensity of staining of the stroma, the cytonuclear morphology and any background content of a smear may facilitate a correct diagnosis. The differences are at best subtle and, on occasion, definitive interpretation may not be feasible (see Adenoid cystic carcinoma, p. 243).50,65,66
The malignant counterpart of basal cell adenoma is basal cell adenocarcinoma.