Chapter 2 Nutritional assessment and therapies
With contribution from Dr Antigone Kouris-Blazos
Introduction
The importance of nutrition in general medical practice has paralleled the increasing prevalence of lifestyle related disorders such as obesity, diabetes, and heart disease. In fact, alongside dermatology and psychological disorders, nutritional disorders are among the most common problems encountered by doctors and there is pressure for the general practitioner to provide competent nutritional assessment, diagnosis and therapy.1 It has been estimated that over 70% of patients seen in general practice are at high risk of having or developing a nutritional deficiency and many patients will exhibit symptoms suggestive of nutritional inadequacy or imbalance which is contributing to their illness.2, 3
The Australian National Health Survey in 2004–5 reported that 86% of Australians between 18–64 years do not consume the recommended 5 serves of vegetables each day and 46% do not consume the recommended 2 serves of fruit each day.4 In 2008 rising petrol and food prices (especially for fresh produce but not for processed/take away foods) were reported to potentially affect shopping trends with less fresh produce being purchased.5 Furthermore, the costs of healthy foods such as bread and milk is rising far greater than the cost of nutrient poor energy dense foods (such as cakes, soft drinks and biscuits), which will impact on food choices and the diet in lower socioeconomic groups.6
This may be further compounded by emerging evidence from the UK and US (Australian data lacking) that there has been declining levels of minerals in our fruit and vegetables over the last 50 years, especially for magnesium dropping by about 45% (see page 23 ‘Dietary history and assessing food and nutrient intake’). Markovic and Natoli report paradoxical nutrient deficiencies such as zinc, iron, vitamin C and D and folate in the obese and overweight due to eating high-energy foods that are also high in saturated fats, salt and sugar, with poor nutrient content.7 The authors note that this condition is under-recognised and therefore not treated. The Public Health Association of Australia released a report in 2009 ‘A Future for our Food: addressing public health, sustainability and equity from paddock to plate’ outlining the urgent need for Australian food policy to encourage food choices that are environmentally sustainable and address the re-emergence of nutrient-deficiency related diseases.8
The Australian dietary guidelines and core food groups are currently undergoing revision. The Public Health Association of Australia would like to see the new guidelines address the re-emergence of nutrient-deficiency related disease and food sustainability. Specific recommendations include: reduced total intake of animal products; reduced reliance on ruminant meat; promotion of sustainable proteins, especially legumes, nuts, eggs and chicken; promotion of seasonal fruit and vegetables, legumes and grains that are grown using production methods appropriate to the region. The report highlights that shifting less than 1 day per week’s worth of calories from red meat and dairy products to chicken, fish, eggs, or legume-based diet achieves more green house gas reduction than buying all locally sourced food. In addition, consuming less meat and more plant-based foods may be 1 type of measure that will lead to increased sustainability and reduced environmental costs of food production systems.8
The Australian National Children’s Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey also highlights the growing epidemic of obesity in children — estimated at 17% of children considered overweight and 6% obese in Australia — with poor quality diets with significant nutritional shortfalls, particularly vitamin D, E, iodine and iron.9
Suboptimal intake of vitamins from diet is common in the general population, particularly children and the elderly, and a risk factor for chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease, neural tube defects, colon and breast cancer, osteopenia and fractures.10
Nutritional assessment will identify the high-risk patient (see Table 2.1) for nutrient inadequacies or excesses which in turn will contribute to a nutritional diagnosis. Once the diagnosis is made it is then possible to put in place the nutritional therapy of the patient.
(Source: adapted from Wahlqvist M, Kouris-Blazos A. Nutrition — is diet enough? J Comp Med 2002: 46)11
Nutritional assessment is based on information gathered from:
Micronutrient | Signs |
---|---|
Vitamin A | |
Vitamin B1 | |
Vitamin B2 | |
Vitamin B3 | |
Vitamin B6 | |
Vitamin B12 | |
Vitamin B complex/folate | |
Vitamin C | |
Vitamin D | |
Calcium (Ca) and/or magnesium (Mg) | Positive Chvostek sign |
Iron (Fe) | Koilonychia, leucoplakia, Plummer–Vinson syndrome |
Zinc (Zn) | Acne, stretch marks, white spots on nail |
Iodine (I) | Weight gain |
Medical history
Signs and symptoms of nutritional deficiencies
Clinical symptoms and anthropometric measurements will provide further clues to the nutritional puzzle. However, symptoms (manifestations reported by the patient) and signs (observations made by a clinician) can occur late in the development of the nutritional problem. Thus diagnosis of a nutritional deficiency cannot usually be made solely on the basis of a clinical examination. This is mainly because many nutrition-related signs and symptoms are non-specific and can occur for non-nutritional reasons. Usually the presence of a group of related clinical signs and symptoms is a better indication than a single sign or symptom.12 For example, the finding of follicular hyperkeratosis isolated to the back of a patient’s arms is a fairly common, normal finding. On the other hand if it is widespread on a person who consumes little fruit and vegetables and smokes regularly (increasing vitamin C requirements) vitamin C deficiency is a possible cause. Not surprisingly, the tissues with the fastest turnover rates are the most likely to show signs of nutrient deficiencies or excesses e.g. hair, skin and lingual papillae (an indirect reflection of the status of the villae of the gut)13 (see Tables 2.2 and 2.3 for clinical signs and symptoms of possible nutritional deficiencies).
A thorough medical and nutritional history, together with a thorough physical examination is necessary to detect nutrient deficiencies (occasionally this may be subtle i.e. nutritional insufficiency). When taking a nutritional history, if limited by time, ask patients to recall what they ate and drank in the last 24–48 hours and/or ask them to bring a 1-week food diary at their next consultation. If time permits, then a more extensive dietary assessment would be helpful as discussed under Dietary history and assessing food and nutrient intake in this chapter. Examples of symptoms suggestive of nutrient deficiencies include gum bleeding (vitamin C), numbness of feet (folic acid and B1 deficiency), night blindness (vitamin A), poor immunity and recurrent infections (vitamins A, C, D and zinc), poor appetite (B group vitamins and zinc), muscle cramps (calcium, magnesium), tremor (magnesium), poor memory (B group vitamins, folic acid and various minerals e.g. magnesium), loss of libido (B group vitamins, folic acid), tiredness (any nutrient), mood disorders (B group vitamins, vitamin C and zinc), poor wound healing (protein, zinc, vitamin C), sore tongue (several B group vitamins) and loss of taste (zinc). Physical examination of the patient may identify a number of signs suggestive of nutrient deficiency (see Tables 2.2 and 2.3).
Clinical symptoms and signs | Consider low intake/deficiency (may warrant blood/urine/faeces testing) |
---|---|
HEAD | |
appetite poor | Zni, v, Mgiii, Feiii, B1vi, B3vi, folatevi, excess vit Ai |
nausea (esp with fatty foods) | B3vi |
fatigue/tiredness/irritable | B6vi, B12vi, folatevi, Zni, v, vi, vit Cvi, Feiii, vi, chromium (Cr)vi, thyroid, excess vit Av, proteinvi |
sugar cravings/hyperglycaemia | insulin resistance, Mg, Criii, v, vi, Zn, vit E |
moody/depressed | proteinvi, B1vi, B3iii, B6iii, vi, B12vi, vit Cvi, Mgvi, Zniii, iodine, thyroid, vit D |
anxiety/agitation | Crvi, Mgvi, vit Dvi |
migraine | B2vi, coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) |
headache | B3iii, B12vi, folatevi, Feiii, Mg if cervicocranial, excess vit Ai, iii |
sleep disturbance | B6vi, Mgvi, vit Cvi |
sleep onset delay | vit Dvi |
poor dream recall | B6vi |
insomnia/restless sleep | vit Dvi, Cavi, B3iii |
non-refreshing sleep | Mgvi |
night sweats-back of head/scalp | vit Dvi |
low libido | Fe (women) iii, Zn (men), low testosterone, thyroid |
impaired memory/cognition/dementia | B1iv, vi, B12iii, iv, vi, B3iii, iv, v, folateiv, vi, Fevi, Znvi, iodine |
HAIR/SCALP | |
hair thinning/loss/alopecia | proteiniv, B2vi, EFAvi, Zniii, vi, Fevi, Biotini, iii, v, vi, excess vit Aiii, excess selenium (Seiii) thyroidi, iodine |
dry dull hair | essential fatty acid (EFA)vi, vit Avi |
easily plucked hair | proteiniv |
dry coarse/brittle hair | proteiniv, biotiniv, Fevi, Zni, vi, Iodine, hypothyroid, EFAvi, excess vit Ai, iii |
depigmentation/dyschromotrichia | copper (Cu)i, Sei |
hair growth arrest | Zni |
diaphoresis of scalp (night) | vit Dvi |
dry flaking hair and scalp | vit A, Zn, Se |
dandruff | Znvi, Mgvi, biotinvi, Se |
prematurely graying hair | Cuvi, Biotinvi, vit B12iii, vi |
coiled/cork screw hairs | vit Ciii (hair shaft flat instead of round in cross section) |
EYES | |
tearing/burning/itching | vit B2v |
dark/crimson under eye circles | Fe, allergyvi, liver problems |
vit Ai, vi, Zni, Biotiniii (conjunctivitis) | |
pale conjunctiva | Feiii |
muddy sclera | vit Cvi |
yellow sclera | liver functioni, vi |
photosensitivity | vit B2iii, vi, Zniii |
bitot spots/white thick patches | vit Ai, Zni |
impaired night vision | vit Aiii, vi, Zniii |
long sightedness | vit Dvi |
impaired visual acuity/blurred | EFAvi, xs vit Ai |
pterygium (thickness) | vit Cvi, B3vi, EFAvi |
twitching eye/spasms facial muscles | Mgi, iii, vi, Cai, iii, Ki |
macular/retinal degeneration | age, lutein, zeaxanthin, excess blood sugar |
NOSE | |
scaling/red folds nasolabial seborrhea | vit B2iii, vi (red greasy folds), B6iii, omega-6iii (dry folds) |
poor smell/anosmia | Znv, vi, vit Av |
EARS | |
noise intolerance | Mgvi |
post aural flush | Znvi, EFAvi |
tinnitus | Feiii |
TONGUE/MOUTH | |
vit B3i, iii, iv, v, B12i, iii, iv, v, folatei, iv, v, Fei, iv, v, vi | |
bright red smooth/glossitis | vit B2i, iv, B6i, iii, iv, v, B12i, iv, folatei, iv, v, Fei, iv, v, vi, biotini, v |
large beefy tongue | hypothyroidi, iodinei |
magenta/blue tongue | vit B2i, iii, v, Biotini |
white/pale smooth | Fei |
yellow/brown tongue | bowel dysfunction/dysbiosisvi, low HCLvi |
berry like red tongue | vit B complexi |
fissured/creviced tongue | vit B3iv, v |
scalloped tongue | Mgvi, vit B3vi |
strawberry tip/cherry tip tongue | vit B3vi, B6vi |
burning sensation of mouth/throat | Dvi |
lips cheilosis (burning/soreness) | vit B2iii, iv, v, B3iii, iv, B6iv, v |
angular stomatitis | vit B1i, B2i, iii, iv, v, B3i, iii, iv, B6iii, iv, folatev, B12i, v, Fei |
halitosis | vit B3vi, low HCL, dysbiotic bacteria, hypothyroid; liver problems |
periodontal disease/loose teeth | vit Cvi, CoQ10vi, Cavi |
bleeding gums/gingivitis | vit Ci, iii, iv, B2iv, vitKvi, xs vit A (red gingiva around teeth)i, iii |
gum recession | proteinvi, CoQ10vi |
mouth ulcers | vit B12vi, vit Avi, folatevi |
crimson crescents back of mouth | food sensitiviesvi |
intense thirst | xs vit Dvi, B1/wet beri beriiii |
impaired taste | Zni, v, vit Aiii |
loss of tooth enamel | Caiv |
HANDS/NAILS | |
finger pulp atrophy | proteinvi |
cold hands | Feiii, Mgvi, vit Evi, EFAvi, thyroid |
vertical corrugations — pronounced (beaded nails) | vit Bii, proteinvi, Znvi, diabetesii, thyroidii, Addisonsii |
vertical corrugations — unpronounced | Agei, RAi, PVDi, Lichen planusi |
pronounced central ridge | Fei, folatei, proteini |
horizontal grooves/Beau’s lines | proteinvi, past severe illness/surgeryii, MIii, Zni, Sei, Caii |
leukonychia (white spots) | Znvi |
half moons base of nails | vit B6vi |
dry thin brittle nails | proteinvi, malnutritionii EFAvi, Fevi, Ca/osteopeniaii, thyroidii |
peeling/splitting nails | Cavi proteinvi |
spoon shaped/brittle nails | Fei, iii, vi, low cysteine/methioninei, diabetesi |
soft/papery/bitten nails | Znvi, proteinvi |
growth arrest/thickened nails | proteinvi, Zni |
yellow nails | vit Evi |
black/red thickened nails | xs Sei |
egg shell nails | vit Avi |
clubbed nails | lung problemsii, IBDii, coeliacii, hyperthyroidii |
brown nail beds or skin creases | vit B12iii |
white nail beds | Seiii |
paronychia | excess Seiii, Zniii |
MUSCLE | |
generalised muscle pain/ache tender muscles | |
cramps | Caiii, v, Mgvi, vit B5vi, Feiii, K, Na, vit Ciii, vit Dvi |
muscle twitching/spasms (hyper-reflexia) | B6v, Mgi, iii, v, vi, Cai, iii, Ki, vit Dvi |
muscle atrophy face, hands, chest, loss of tissue recoil back of hand | proteinvi, B1vi |
calf/muscle tenderness | vit Ev (intermittent claudication), B complexiv, vi |
muscle weakness/wasting (difficulty up/down stairs)iii | proteiniv, vit Dv, Kv, Ca, thiamin |
decreased muscle reflexes | B complexvi, vit Evi |
SKIN | |
excessive ageing of skin/wrinkles | vit Evi |
perifollicular hyperkeratosis (toad skin) commonly seen on upper arms/thighs | vit Ai, iv, vi, Zni, B complexiii, vit Ciii, v, EFAiii |
perifollicular petechiae/haemorrhages | vit Ci, iii, v, vit Ki, iii (causes petechiae unrelated to hair; sometimes seen with prolonged antibiotic treatment) |
shark skin/dyssebacea (sebum plugs in follicles/face/body) | vit B2iii |
vit B2iii, v(nasolabial/scrotum), vit B3iii, vit B6i, iii, v, Biotinvi, Cui, EFAvi | |
dry scaly/coarse dermatitis | Zniii, v, Iodinei, vit B3iii, omega-6i, iii, omega-3vi, vit Cv, vit E, biotini, v, vitAv, vit A excessi, iii, v |
dry ‘fish scale’, ‘flaky paint’ | vit Aiv, Zniv, v especially on the legs |
hyperpigmentation non scaly macules/patches | insulin resistancevi, vit A, Zniii, v, vit C, vit B12iii, vit B6vi, folateiii, EFA, evening primrose oil (EPO), vit B3iv (see also dermatitis) |
hyperpigmented scaly dermal patches on face/limbs (pellagra) | vit B1, vit B3i, biotini, v, Zniii, v, EFA |
unusual skin rash | vit B6 or excess supplement use |
spider veins | vit Cvi |
liver spots (ceroid accumulation) | vit Evi |
eczema | biotinvi, Zniii, omega-3vi, omega-6/EPOi, iii, gluteni |
rosacea | vit B2, hypochlorhydria/gastric dysfunctionvi, dysbiotic bacteria/H pylori infectionvi |
psoriasis | vit Dvi, EFAvi, vit Aiv, Zniii |
acne | EFAvi, Znvi, vit Avi, vit Ciii, dysbiotic bacteria, bowel dysbiosisvi, high GI diet/insulin resistancevi |
stretchmarks | Znvi, vit Evi, Bvivi |
wound healing/lesions on pressure areas | vit A, B6vi, vit Cv, vi, Zni, iii, v, EFAvi, proteinvi, biotinvi |
easy bruising | vit Kiv, vi, dysbiotic bacteriavi, protein, vit Civ, vi, blood thinning medication |
blood mottling arms/legs | vit B6vi |
itchy skin/rashes | liver problems |
NERVES/PAIN/BONES | |
impaired coordination/balance, disorientation/ataxic gait | vit B1i, vi, B12iii, v (neurological changes can occur without haematologic changes), B3iv, vit Eiv, vi |
neuropathy (weakness, ataxia, pins/needles, parasthesia, foot/wrist drop, reduced tendon reflexes, numbness of fingers/feet/lips/tongue fine tactile sense, vibratory sense, position sense) | vit B1i, iv, vi, B2iii, vi, B6iii, iv, B12iv, v, carnitine, EPO, vit B6 toxicityiii, folateiii, Mgi, Cai, Ki, omega-3iii, Criii, v Fevi, vit Eiv, v, lipoic acid |
neuralgia/paralysis/paresthesia | vit B1iv, B3iii, B12iii, iv, v Mgiv, v |
tetany | Caiv, v, Mgiv, Kv |
diminished reflexes | Iodineiv |
postural hypotension | vit B6/B complexvi, Fevi (general hypotension) |
bone/joint pain | vit Civ, v, vi, xs vit Aiv, v, vit Div, v, Cav, omega-3vi, Znvi, Boronvi |
low bone density | excess vit Av Cav, Mgv, vit Dv, Cav, Zn, vit K |
DIGESTION | |
constipation/bloating | Feiii, B3vi, low HCL/enzymes, gluten, food intolerances, dysbiosis, candida management, vit D excess |
diarrhoea | Feiii, excess Mg/vit Ci, Zni, B3iii, vi, B12iii folatev, biotinv, fructose, fructans |
belching/flatulence/reflux | vit B12iii, low hydrochloric acid (HCL), H Pylori, allergen, lactose, fructose |
poor digestion | vit B3vi, low stomach acid (HCI)vi |
MENSTRUAL | |
delayed/<flow periods/irregular oligomenorrhoea/sub-fertility | Feiii, vit Evi, EFAsvi, insulin resistancevi, Znvi |
mastalgia | vit Evi, vit Avi, omega-3vi/EFA imbalancevi |
PMS | vit B6vi, Cavi, Mgvi, EFAvi |
dysmennorrhoea/menorrhagea | Cavi |
LEGS/FEET | |
heels — hyperkeratosis/dry/cracked | vit Evi, EFAvi |
soles — hyperkeratosis | vit Avi |
cold feet/<peripheral perfusion | vit Evi, EFAvi, Mgvi, vit B6, thyroid (vit A, Zn, I, Fe) |
burning paresthesias in feet | vit B5iii, B1iii |
arch collapse | proteinvi |
calf muscle tenderness | vit Evi, B1iii |
oedema | K, Mg, vit B1i, iii, Feiii, proteiniv, quercetin |
GROWTH | |
poor | Fei, Zni, vi, Iodinei, iii, proteini, energyi, vit Di, Ca, omega-6iii, vitAv |
IMMUNITY/INFECTIONS/CANCER | |
immuno-dysfunction | Zniii Sevi, vit Cvi, vit Evi, vit D |
Important note: The list in Table 2.3 is not definitive and is based on combined clinical experience and scientific evidence. Assessment and treatment should be based on your own clinical judgment (i.e. dietary history and physical examination) and confirmed with pathology testing. Symptoms may also occur from other non-nutritional related diseases.
i McLaren DS. A Colour Atlas and Text of Diet-Related Disorders. 2nd edn. London England: Wolfe & Mosby — Year book Europe Ltd, 1992.
ii Medscape. Examining the Fingernails When Evaluating Presenting Symptoms in Elderly Patients. Online. Available: www.medscape.com (accessed 7 Aug 2008).
iii McLaren DS. Clinical manifestations of human vitamin and mineral disorders: a resume. In: Shils M, Olson JA, Shike M, Ross C. Modern Nutrition in Health and Disease. 9th edn. Williams & Wilkins, 1999;485–503.
iv Newton MJ, Halsted CH. Clinical and functional assessment of adults. In: Shils M, Olson JA, Shike M, Ross C. Modern Nutrition in Health and Disease. 9th edn. Williams & Wilkins, 1999;895–902.
v Heimburger DC, Ard JD. Handbook of Clinical Nutrition. 4th edn. Mosby Elsevier 2006.
vi Sydney-Smith M. Nutritional Assessment. J Comp Medicine 2006; Jan-Feb 28–40; and Nutritional Assessment Workshop Seminar slides, March 2008.
Anthropometry
Anthropometry is a measurement and study of the human body and its parts and capacities and can provide information on body muscle mass, fat reserves and fat distribution. Unintentional weight loss during illness often reflects loss of lean body mass, especially if rapid and not caused by diuresis. Body mass index (BMI) alone is not ideal in determining health risk because it does not reflect the amount of muscle or distribution of fat mass. The waist circumference is a good indicator of abdominal obesity but it does not differentiate between visceral/internal fat (the one linked to chronic diseases) and the more inert subcutaneous abdominal fat. Convenient and inexpensive electrical impedance devices are increasingly being used by clinicians to determine muscle mass, fat mass, visceral fat and body water. When assessing health risks associated with a patient’s weight, it may be useful to remember that higher weight in the elderly has been associated with lower mortality risk — staying in the ‘normal’ BMI range during young adulthood is recommended but slowly gaining weight during the elderly years does not seem to pose a health risk. On the other hand, obesity during young adulthood and being underweight during the elderly years leads to higher mortality rates.14 Furthermore, if a patient does a lot of exercise but is still overweight this poses a lower mortality risk than being slim and unfit.15 There is also emerging evidence of a subgroup of healthy obese that could be genetically determined or could relate to the dietary pathway in becoming overweight. For example, becoming overweight on a Mediterranean diet may not pose the same health risk as becoming overweight on a Western diet. This possibility has been identified in elderly Greek migrants in Australia that despite being overweight had lower mortality rates than their leaner Anglo-Celtic counterparts.16