, Haiyan Liu1 and Jun Zhang2
(1)
Department of Laboratory Medicine, Geisinger Health System, Danville, PA, USA
(2)
Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology, Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, AZ, USA
Keywords
LiverHepatic abscessGranulomatous inflammationEchinococcal (hydatid) cystHepatocellular adenomaFocal nodular hyperplasiaCirrhosisRegenerative nodulesBile duct adenoma and hamartomaCavernous hemangiomaAngiomyolipomaLymphangiomaLymphangiomatosisInfantile hemangiomaMesenchymal hamartomaSolitary fibrous tumorHepatocellular carcinomaHepatocellular carcinomaFibrolamellar variantHepatoblastomaIntrahepatic cholangiocarcinomaCombined hepatocellular-cholangiocarcinomaAngiosarcomaEpithelioid hemangioendotheliomaInflammatory pseudotumorSolitary fibrous tumorEmbryonal (undifferentiated) sarcomaExtrarenal malignant rhabdoid tumorFollicular dendritic cell tumorSarcomaCarcinomaGastrointestinal stromal tumorLymphomaGerm cell tumorMetastasisNeuroendocrine tumorMelanomaLiver fatty acid-binding protein (L-FABP)Hepatocyte nuclear factor 1-alpha (HNF-1a)Serum amyloid A (SSA)/C-reactive protein (CRP)Beta-cateninGlutamine synthetase (GS)CK7CK20CD34ReticulinArginase-1HepPar-1Glypican-3Alpha-fetoproteinHeat-shock protein 70 (HSP70)ClusterinCD10p-CEAMOC31pVHLHMB45CD31ERGGATA3ERPAX8TTF1SOX10SALL4CDX2SATB2ATRX/DAXXSummary of Pearls and Pitfalls
Fine needle aspiration (FNA) and small needle core biopsies of the liver under a guidance of computed tomography (CT) or ultrasound (US) are popular procedures to obtain a diagnosis from a mass lesion. It is a very useful approach in the diagnosis of malignant liver neoplasms, with sensitivity ranging from 75% to 94% and specificity ranging from 87% to 100%.
Approximately 95% of malignant liver tumors are metastasis, and the majority of other malignant tumors are hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC).
In order to obtain a definitive diagnosis, a cellblock preparation or thin needle core biopsy in conjunction with immunohistochemical (IHC) stains is strongly encouraged for every FNA of the liver.
FNA of the liver cannot differentiate among the benign lesions of hepatocellular adenoma (HCA), focal nodular hyperplasia, and regenerative nodule in cirrhosis .
Two important diagnostic issues are frequently encountered in the FNA of the liver. One is to differentiate well-differentiated HCC from benign/reactive hepatic lesion, and the other is to distinguish poorly differentiated HCC from cholangiocarcinoma or metastatic carcinomas or even sarcomas.
Glypican- 3, heat-shock protein 70 (HSP70 ), glutamine synthetase (GS ) , and clusterin are useful markers in diagnosing a well-differentiated HCC.
Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP ) is a specific, after exclusion of germ cell tumors and other tumors, but insensitive marker (about 25%) in the detection of HCC on tissue section.
Arginase-1 is a more specific marker than hepatocyte paraffin-1 (HepPar-1 ) in confirming a hepatocellular origin when working on a tumor of unknown origin.
Approximately 70% of intrahepatic cholangiocarcinomas (IHCCs) are positive for von Hippel-Lindau tumor suppressor gene protein (pVHL ); in contrast, metastatic adenocarcinomas, including those from the pancreas and extrahepatic biliary tract, are negative for pVHL.
Albumin by ribonucleic acid (RNA) in situ hybridization has been reported to be detectable in nearly 100% of HCCs and IHCCs and the majority of hepatoid carcinomas.
Vascular tumors of the liver tend to have a bloody and hypocellular smear; therefore, avoid calling a smear non-diagnostic before excluding a vascular tumor. Bland spindled endothelial cells may be mistaken for other mesenchymal lesions.
When working on a spindle cell lesion, even if no lipomatous component is seen, an angiomyolipoma should be included in the differential diagnoses. The epithelioid variant of angiomyolipoma can mimic other tumors, such as HCC, clear cell renal cell carcinoma (RCC), adrenocortical carcinoma, and melanoma.
Liver Lesions, Neoplasms, and Tumors in the 2010 World Health Organization (WHO) Classification , Modified1
Normal/reactive liver
Infection
Hepatic abscess
Granulomatous inflammation
Echinococcal (hydatid) cyst
Benign neoplasms/lesions
HCA
Focal nodular hyperplasia
Cirrhosis
Regenerative nodules
Bile duct adenoma and hamartoma
Cavernous hemangioma
Angiomyolipoma (perivascular epithelioid cell tumor [PEComa])
Lymphangioma
Lymphangiomatosis
Infantile hemangioma
Mesenchymal hamartoma
Solitary fibrous tumor
Premalignant lesions
Intraductal papillary neoplasm with low-, intermediate-, or high-grade dysplasia
Mucinous cystic neoplasm with low-, intermediate-, or high-grade dysplasia
Malignant neoplasms
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC)
HCC, fibrolamellar variant
Hepatoblastoma
Intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma (IHCC)
Combined hepatocellular-cholangiocarcinoma
Intraductal papillary neoplasm with an associated invasive carcinoma
Mucinous cystic neoplasm with an associated invasive carcinoma
Angiosarcoma
Epithelioid hemangioendothelioma
Other sarcomas
Germ cell tumors
Lymphomas
Rare primary lesions/tumors
Secondary tumors
Normal Cytology of the Liver
Hepatocytes (Figs. 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, 7.6, 7.7, and 7.8)
Fig. 7.1
Normal hepatocytes with round and centrally located nuclei with prominent nucleoli (Diff-Quik)
Fig. 7.2
Normal hepatocytes (Papanicolaou [Pap] stain)
Fig. 7.3
Hepatocytes with steatosis
Fig. 7.4
Hepatocytes with lipofuscin
Fig. 7.5
Hepatocytes with bile (Diff-Quik)
Fig. 7.6
Hepatocytes with bile (Pap stain)
Fig. 7.7
Reactive hepatocytes with prominent nucleoli
Fig. 7.8
Two-dimensional sheets of benign duct epithelium cells. The nuclei are round to ovoid, same size or slightly larger than one red blood cell, evenly distributed nuclear chromatin, smooth nuclear membranes, and indistinct nucleoli (Diff-Quik)
Large polygonal cells singly, in ribbons, or in large tissue fragments.
Round and centrally located nuclei with prominent nucleoli.
Binucleation and intranuclear inclusion are common.
Low nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio with abundant granular cytoplasm.
Bile Duct Epithelial Cells
Two-dimensional sheets of variable sizes, with a scant amount of cytoplasm and poorly defined cytoplasmic borders.
The cell borders may be prominent, forming an orderly honeycomb appearance.
The nuclei are round to ovoid, the same size or slightly larger than one red blood cell, evenly distributed nuclear chromatin, smooth nuclear membranes, and indistinct nucleoli (Fig. 7.9a, b).
Fig. 7.9
(a, b) Benign duct cell s and hepatocytes on Diff-Quik (a) and Pap stain (b)
Hepatic Abscess
Cytological Features
Numerous acute inflammatory cells and necrotic debris as shown in Fig. 7.10.
Fig. 7.10
Hepatic abscess with acute inflammatory cells and necrotic debris
Culture is needed.
Cellblock preparation for special stains.
Differential Diagnosis
Bacteria, amoeba, fungus, or neoplasms
Granulomatous Inflammation
Cytological Features
Aggregates of epithelioid histiocytes, multinucleated giant cells, and chronic inflammatory cells with or without necrosis, as shown in Fig. 7.11
Fig. 7.11
Granulomatous inflammation
Histology
Aggregates of epithelioid histiocytes, multinucleated giant cells, and chronic inflammatory cells with or without necrosis
Differential Diagnosis
Infection, such as tuberculosis, fungus, parasites
Sarcoidosis
Reaction to foreign materials
Neoplasms, Hodgkin’s lymphoma, T-cell lymphoma, and seminoma
Echinococcal (Hydatid) Cyst
Clinical Features
Anaphylactic shock has been reported as an occasional complication of the FNA.
Cytological Features (Fig. 7.12)
Fragments of the laminated membrane
Fig. 7.12
Hydatid cyst showing hooks
Scolices
Hooklets
Hepatocellular Adenoma
Clinical Features
Young female, usually under age 30.
Long-term use of oral contraceptives or androgenic steroids.
Other nonhormonal risk factors such as glycogenosis type 1 and 3, galactosemia, familial polyposis coli, obesity, etc.
Sizes are variable from microscopic focus to 20 cm .
Cytological Features
Normal-appearing or mildly atypical hepatocytes, singly or in groups or sheets (Fig. 7.13a–c)
Fig. 7.13
(a–c) HCA with benign hepatocytes and no ductal cells on an FNA smear (a), on cellblock (b), and reticulin showing hepatocytes of 1–2 cells in thickness (c)
Normal nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio with abundant granular cytoplasm
Decreased numbers or lack of bile duct epithelial cells
Histology
Benign hepatocytes arranged in plates, one or two cells thick (Fig. 7.14a–d).
Fig. 7.14
(a–d) HCA showing hepatocytes arranged in layers of one to two cells in thickness and absence of portal tracts (a–c) and reticulin highlighting hepatocytes of 1–2 cells in thickness (d)
Absence of portal tracts with presence of isolated arteries.
Tumoral hepatocytes may show steatotic, clear, or pigmented cytoplasm.
Focal pseudoglandular formation can be seen.
Minimal nuclear atypia and no mitosis.
Biopsy of adjacent nontumoral liver to determine the presence of absence of cirrhosis is important.
HCA has been recently subclassified into several groups: hepatocyte nuclear factor 1-alpha (HNF-1a )-inactivated HCA (35–40%), beta-catenin-activated HCA (10–15%), inflammatory HCA (>50%), and unclassified HCA (<10%).
Beta-catenin-activated HCA has an increased risk of malignant transformation .
Immunohistochemistry
A panel of IHC markers including liver fatty acid-binding protein (L-FABP ), HNF-1a , serum amyloid A (SSA) /C-reactive protein (CRP ), beta-catenin, and GS has been reported to be useful in this subclassification. The immunoreactivity to each IHC marker for each subtype of HCA is summarized in Table 7.1.
Table 7.1.
Summary of useful IHC markers in subclassification of HCA
Markers/diagnosis
HNF-1a -inactivated HCA
Beta-catenin-activated HCA
Inflam-matory HCA
Unclassified HCA
L-FABP
−
+
+
+
GS
−
+
−
−
Beta-catenin (N+)
−
+
−
−
SAA/CRP
−
−
+
−
Differential Diagnosis
Normal liver
Focal nodular hyperplasia
Regenerative nodules
Cirrhosis
Focal Nodular Hyperplasia
Clinical Features
Nodule usually contains a central scar.
Cytological Features
Normal-appearing or mildly atypical hepatocytes in singly or in groups or sheets
Normal nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio with abundant granular cytoplasm
Increased numbers of bile duct epithelial cells
Histology
Benign hepatocellular nodules arranged in plates no more than two cells thick (Figs. 7.15a–d and 7.16a–d).
Fig. 7.15
(a–d) Focal nodular hyperplasia with benign hepatocytes arranged in layers of less than two cells in thickness, lack of portal tract, stromal inflammatory infiltrate, and ductular reaction on a core biopsy
Fig. 7.16
(a–d) Focal nodular hyperplasia with benign hepatocytes arranged in layers of less than two cells in thickness, lack of portal tract, stromal inflammatory infiltrate, and ductular reaction on a resection specimen. Note the reticulin stain (c) and trichrome stain (d)
Central scar containing one or more large dystrophic vessels and many small arterioles.
Portal-like structures with arteries only, absence of veins or bile ducts.
Stromal inflammatory infiltration, cholate stasis, and ductular reaction at the parenchymal-stromal interface.
Cytokeratin (CK)7 highlights the prominent ductular reaction.
Sinusoids adjacent to arteries are lined by cluster of differentiation (CD)34-positive endothelium .
Differential Diagnosis
Normal liver
HCA
Regenerative nodules
Cirrhosis
Bile Duct Adenoma/Hamartoma
Clinical Features
Usually multiple small nodules
Cytological Features
Hypocellular specimen with increased numbers of benign to mildly atypical bile duct epithelial cells
Normal hepatocytes
Histology (Fig. 7.17a, b)
Bile duct adenoma is characterized by a proliferation of normal-appearing small bile ducts surrounded by connective tissue with entrapped portal tract forming a nodule or multiple nodules, usually in a subcapsular location. Nuclear atypia, mitosis, and intraluminal bile are usually absent.
Fig. 7.17
(a, b) Bile duct adenoma
Hamartoma is formed by a proliferation of bile ducts in anastomotic channels containing bile in a fibrotic stroma .
Differential Diagnosis
Cirrhosis
Focal nodular hyperplasia
Cholangiocarcinoma
Metastatic well-differentiated adenocarcinoma
Angiomyolipoma (PEComa)
Clinical Features
Most common benign tumor of the kidney
Cluster of spindle cells or epithelioid smooth muscle cells.
Fig. 7.18
Angiomyolipoma with spindle cells and fat cells
Fig. 7.19
Angiomyolipoma on cellblock section
Adipocytes.
Thickened wall blood vessels.
The ratio of the above three components is variable from one case to another.
Extramedullary hematopoiesis.
Histology
Smooth muscle proliferation admixed with various proportions of adipose tissue and thick-walled hyalinized blood vessels.
Smooth muscle cells can be spindled or epithelioid. The epithelioid cells can have clear or oncocytic cytoplasm.
Immunohistochemistry
Positive for smooth muscle actin (SMA), human melanoma black 45 (HMB45 ), and melanoma antigen recognized by T cells-1 (Mart-1)
Can be positive for CD117 and desmin
Usually negative for S100
Differential Diagnosis
HCC
RCC
Adrenocortical carcinoma
Sarcoma
Carcinoma
Granulomatous inflammation
Hemangioma
Clinical Features
The most common benign neoplasm of the liver
Reported in up to 20% of autopsy studies
More common in young adult females
May increase in size or even rupture during pregnancy
Bloody sample with low cellularity and normal hepatocytes in the background
Fig. 7.20
Hemangioma with few benign elongated spindle cells
Fig. 7.21
Hemangioma with small cluster of three-dimensional coiled elongated spindle cells
Fig. 7.22
Tissue section of hemangiom a
Scattered, isolated cytologically bland spindle cells
Small clusters of three-dimensional coiled elongated spindle cells
Histology
Most benign vascular tumors are cavernous hemangioma s.
Various-sized blood-filled vascular channels lined by a single layer of flat endothelial cells separated by fibrous septa of various thicknesses.
Differential Diagnosis
Spindle cell tumor if a highly cellular sample is obtained
Granulomatous inflammation
Lymphangioma and lymphangiomatosis
Hepatocellular Carcinoma (HCC)
Clinical Features
Over 90% of primary malignant tumors of the liver are HCCs.
Can be solitary or multiple nodules or even a diffuse infiltrate.
Serum AFP is not a very sensitive or specific marker.
Frequently associated with cirrhosis .
Fibrolamellar-type HCC is not associated with cirrhosis ; mean age of patients is 23; normal serum AFP .
Cytological Features for Well-Differentiated HCC (Figs. 7.23, 7.24, 7.25, 7.26, 7.27, 7.28, 7.29, 7.30, 7.31, 7.32, 7.33, 7.34, 7.35, 7.36, 7.37, 7.38, 7.39, 7.40, and 7.41a–d)
Hypercellular samples with many single cells, thick cores, nets, and sheets.
Fig. 7.23
Hypercellular smears of HCC , low power; hypercellular samples with many single cells, thick cores, nets, and sheets
Fig. 7.24
Well-differentiated HCC with trabeculae (Diff-Quik)
Fig. 7.25
Well-differentiated HCC with trabeculae (Pap stain)
Fig. 7.26
Well-differentiated HCC with bile
Fig. 7.27
Well-differentiated with high nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio (Pap stain)
Fig. 7.28
Numerous naked nuclei
Fig. 7.29
Well-differentiated with pseudoglandular formation (Pap stain)
Fig. 7.30
Tissue with pseudoglands
Fig. 7.31
Well-differentiated HCC; CD34 highlighting the trabecular growth pattern
Fig. 7.32
Well-differentiated HCC; polyclonal CEA showing canalicular staining pattern
Fig. 7.33
(a, b) Well-differentiated HCC on tissue sections
Fig. 7.34
Well-differentiated HCC; lack of reticulin stain
Fig. 7.35
Well-differentiated HCC; positive for glypican- 3
Fig. 7.36
(a–f) Moderately differentiated HCC with pseudoglandular formation on (a) and (b). Note the loss of reticulin in the tumor cells (c), CD34 (d), CD10 (e), and polyclonal CEA (f)
Fig. 7.37
Poorly differentiated HCC showing marked nuclear atypia with giant cells, spindle cells, and atypical mitoses and many pleomorphic naked nuclei
Fig. 7.38
Poorly differentiated HCC (Pap stain)
Fig. 7.39
Poorly differentiated HCC on cellblock
Fig. 7.40
AFP positivity on cellblock
Fig. 7.41
(a–d) Poorly differentiated HCC on core biopsy specimen (a), CD34 (b), arginase-1 (c), and glypican-3 (d)
Hepatocytes more than three cell layers thick wrapped by spindle-shaped endothelial cells are the key to a final diagnosis.
Pseudoglandular formation with bile is another diagnostic feature.
Many naked, large/pleomorphic nuclei.
Hepatocytes with high nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio, large nuclei, prominent nuclei, and intranuclear inclusions.
Clear cell changes.
Steatosis.
Fibrolamellar HCC .
Histology
Architectural patterns: Trabecular pattern, pseudoglandular or acinar pattern, and compact/solid pattern
Cytological variants: Pleomorphic cells, clear cells, fatty changes, spindle cells
Immunohistochemistry and Special Stains
Arginase-1 is positive in both benign and neoplastic liver tissues. It is the most sensitive and specific marker available to identify hepatocellular origin when working on tumor of unknown primary.
HepPar1 is similar to arginase-1 with a lower specificity. It can be positive in other carcinomas.
Glypican- 3 is expressed in fetal liver, reactivated in about 80% of HCCs, including a small HCC and poorly differentiated HCC, and usually negative in normal liver, cirrhosis , benign hepatic lesions, and dysplastic nodules.
GS is frequently positive in HCC (defined as positive in >10% of tumor cells).
HSP70 is upregulated in HCCs, including early HCC (defined as positive in at least 10% of tumor cells), but usually negative in normal hepatocytes and expressed in bile ducts (as an internal positive control) .
Glypican- 3, GS , and HSP70 can serve as a diagnostic panel in the workup of a difficult case.
Clusterin has been reported to be overexpressed in HCC.
AFP is positive in only about 25% of HCC cases.
CD34 highlights neovascular spaces/sinusoidal capillarization; usually no immunoreactivity seen in normal liver and benign hepatic lesions; some immunoreactivity can be seen in the peripheral portion of a cirrhotic nodule.
CD10 and polyclonal carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) show a canalicular staining pattern.
Albumin by RNA in situ hybridization .
Differential Diagnosis for Well-Differentiated HCC
Regenerative nodules in cirrhosis
Focal nodular hyperplasia
HCA
Cytological Features for Moderate and Poorly Differentiated HCC
Hypercellular samples with many singles, thick cores, nets, and sheets
Marked nuclear atypia with giant cells, spindle cells, and atypical mitoses
Many pleomorphic naked nuclei
Differential Diagnosis for Moderately and Poorly Differentiated HCC
Cholangiocarcinoma
Metastatic carcinoma
Table 7.2 summarizes some useful markers in the distinction between HCC and IHCC.
Table 7.2.
Useful markers in the distinction between HCC and IHCC
Marker
HCC
IHCC
CK7
Negative or focally +
+
Arginase-1
+ (90%)
–
MOC31
–
+
pVHL
–
+ (70%)
Variants of HCC
Fibrolamellar Variant (Figs. 7.42, 7.43, 7.44, and 7.45)
Accounts for 0.5–9.0% of HCCs in various studies.
Fig. 7.42
Fibrolamellar HCC
Fig. 7.43
Fibrolamellar HCC – intracytoplasmic pale body
Fig. 7.44
Fibrolamellar HCC – intranuclear inclusion
Fig. 7.45
Fibrolamellar HCC tissue section
More common in North America and European countries.
Most frequently occurs in patients aged 35 years or younger with a peak at age 25.
Non-cirrhotic background.
Central scar in radiologic finding and gross examination.
Nests and bands of large polygonal tumor cells with abundant, granular oncocytic cytoplasm, large vesicular nuclei, and prominent nucleoli, in a distinctive lamellar fibrotic background.
Pseudoglandular formation and cytoplasmic “pale bodies” or “hyaline bodies” can be seen.
CK7 is frequently positive.
Better prognosis than typical HCC .
Scirrhous HCC
Accounts for 5% of HCCs.
Marked fibrotic background, sinusoid-like blood space, and atrophic tumor trabeculae.
Better prognosis than typical HCCs has been reported.
Clear Cell HCC and Sarcomatoid HCC
Lymphoepithelioma-Like Carcinoma
A very rare type of HCC
Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-positive
Intrahepatic Cholangiocarcinoma (IHCC)
Clinical Features
Second most common primary malignant tumor of the liver
Accounting for 5–15% in various study series
Arising from any portion of intrahepatic biliary tree except the right and left hepatic ducts (usually referred to as hilar cholangiocarcinoma or “Klatskin tumor”)
May be associated with sclerosing cholangitis, inflammatory bowel disease, Caroli disease, parasitic infection, hepatolithiasis, non-biliary cirrhosis including hepatitis C, alcoholic liver disease, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), and diabetic mellitus
Radiologic findings similar to HCC
Cytological Features (Fig. 7.49a, b)
Single and crowded groups of atypical epithelial cells
Fig. 7.49
(a, b) Cholangiocarcinoma – single and crowded groups of atypical epithelial cell nuclear enlargement, loss of nuclear polarity, and variation in nuclear sizes
Nuclear enlargement, loss of nuclear polarity, and variation in nuclear sizes
Nuclear contour irregularities, high nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio, and mitoses