Chapter 5 With contributions from Dr Rahul Mukherjee Postgraduate medical training in the United Kingdom has undergone significant reforms in the last decade. Newly qualified doctors embark on a 2-year Foundation Programme to develop core generic skills and take responsibility for patient care. Trainees may then complete specialty training before gaining entrance onto the specialist register or the general practitioner (GP) register. The duration of this additional specialty training varies from 3 to 8 years depending on specialty. During this period, trainees can do a number of things to develop their clinical skills, increase their knowledge and become a better doctor. Foundation Programmes are compulsory for all UK graduating doctors. The programme is intended to streamline training so as to ensure that all junior doctors develop a set of core transferable skills and to reduce the bottleneck when entering the registrar grade. Foundation Programmes are divided into 2 years (FY1 and FY2) that are now usually paired within the same training deanery. FY1 trainees are comparable to the pre-registration house officers in the older system and are frequently still called that. Placements are of variable length between 3 and 6 months, but most programmes have six placements of 4 months each across a 2-year programme. Typically trainees spend a minimum of 4 months in surgery and medicine. During FY2, many programmes contain a general practice placement recognizing the importance of primary care in healthcare delivery in the United Kingdom. During the first year, if not already allocated during your job selection, you will have an opportunity to put forwards your preferences for placements in FY2. Ultimately you should choose your placements based on your interests as well as any gaps you may have in your experience. It will be useful when applying for specialist training posts if you can demonstrate a clear path from your initial foundation jobs to the specialty you wish to pursue. For example, a GP trainee may want initial experience in general medicine and surgery before undertaking specialized rotations in paediatrics and obstetrics/gynaecology. Although it is emphasized that the foundation jobs you undertake will not influence selection to specialist training, most trainees who are successful in securing specialist training posts have demonstrated significant commitment to their specialty through audit experience, logbook of procedures and attendance at relevant courses. Having gained some experience in the specialty you want to go into during foundation training certainly helps but is not mandatory. It may be worth noting that a core commitment of the NHS is to try to accommodate flexible training. This includes the foundation years. Trainees may elect to complete their training less than full time at the outset and the arrangements for this vary between trusts. Some trusts offer a slot-sharing arrangement, for example, where two trainees share one full time post and the pro rata out of hours. It is possible to take time out of the Foundation Programme (e.g. due to maternity leave), but this may lead to a delay in the completion date of your programme. In these circumstances, it is advisable to speak to your Foundation Programme training director and educational supervisor at the earliest opportunity to ensure that appropriate procedures are in place and arrangements made for your return to training. In addition to the clinical Foundation Programmes, there are a number of academic programmes (around 400 in the United Kingdom) where trainees have protected time to develop their research, teaching or leadership skills. These are prestigious posts and form part of the Integrated Academic Training Pathway to help develop the next generation of academic clinicians and research leaders. All academic trainees must complete the same clinical competencies as standard clinical trainees but get less ‘clinical’ time to do so. This means that you have to be highly motivated and organized to fulfil your academic and clinical aspirations. During your academic Foundation Programme, you will have a period of ‘protected research time’. The protected research time can be delivered in a number of ways. Most jobs provide a dedicated 4-month block with no clinical duties, but others offer a day release every week or even weekly blocks of research separated by longer periods of clinical work. Some trainees choose to spend this time in a laboratory developing their knowledge of basic science whilst others complete a clinical project. This protected time gives an invaluable opportunity to produce work that can be presented at national and international conferences as well as published in peer-reviewed journals. Completing an academic Foundation Programme also demonstrates your commitment to a particular specialty and gives a distinct advantage when applying for the next stage in the Integrated Academic Training Pathway – the Academic Clinical Fellowship phase. Your meetings with your educational supervisor should be focused on the progress of your training. This will largely be based on your assessments. Although a rapidly changing area, the assessment tools currently in use include the following: You should pick a range of assessors from amongst your peers, consultants and other healthcare professionals (including physiotherapists, pharmacists, nursing staff and healthcare assistants) and ask them to complete specific questionnaires about your clinical skills and conduct on the wards. You also complete a self-assessment and the results are collected and presented to you in your meetings with the educational supervisor. This exercise is aimed at finding out your strengths and weaknesses. It can be very demoralizing to discover your weaknesses (or what other people think are your weaknesses) but you should not shy away from selecting more critical assessors. Although compulsory for progression, these assessments are not currently used in any competitive sense so you should choose assessors who are likely to give you an honest appraisal. The most critical assessments are often the ones that help you learn the most about yourself and how you are perceived by different members of the multi-disciplinary team. It can also be very useful to gain feedback from patients, and some specialty programmes are beginning to incorporate ‘patient surveys’ into the assessment process. You will have to find several clinical scenarios to be assessed on. These are extremely varied and can be found in the curriculum of your Foundation Programme on your ePortfolio. The assessor is usually a senior registrar, consultant or GP. It can be difficult to arrange an occasion where a real clinical scenario, assessor and you coincide. You may be able to go to a clinic and be observed whilst taking a history or doing a clinical examination. The post-take ward round can also be a good place to conduct a brief clinical exam in front of your consultant. It is usually best to complete the assessment on ePortfolio as soon as you have done it, but often sending your consultant a reminder via an ePortfolio link at a later time, with a brief summary of the clinical scenario, is needed. You will have to find a variety of clinical opportunities to demonstrate your prowess. The procedural skills do not need to be complex; they can be fairly routine and straightforward (e.g. venepuncture, taking an ECG) and will happen at least once a day on every ward. As such, there will be no shortage of occasions to be assessed. That said, if you have a mind to go into a particular specialty (e.g. anaesthetics) an interview panel will probably be more impressed if you pull out examples of several central line insertions you have done than if you can only prove your ability to take blood. The trick again is to find the assessor first and then offer to perform the task that the assessor was going to do. It can often be difficult to find the opportunities to perform certain procedures (e.g. chest drain insertion, central line insertion, abdominal paracentesis). Some hospitals have pleural intervention units where a respiratory physician with a special interest may perform lists where they insert chest drains under ultrasound guidance. It may be worth getting in touch with these consultants and expressing your interest to observe one of their lists and perhaps get an opportunity to do one yourself under supervision. If your hospital has an interventional radiology unit, they may have lists when they perform procedures under ultrasound guidance. Cardiology units will routinely perform diagnostic angiography via femoral/radial arterial line insertion. This is the more traditional format where you pick cases you have seen to discuss with your consultant or other senior medical team member. History-taking, examination, differential diagnosis, investigation, management, record-keeping and ethical aspects are areas you will have to cover. If you see surgical pre-admissions or patients on an acute take, then these are easy opportunities to complete the task. If you rotate through accident and emergency, this also offers many opportunities for near complete clinical encounters. There are minimum numbers of assessments you will need to do, but do not be limited by them. The more assessments you have, the more you will learn and the more you will have in your logbook as evidence of adequate training. Surgical logbooks are not essential at foundation level of training, but if you are an aspiring surgeon it is useful to keep a log that you can show at interview to the panel. In addition to these ‘minimum’ prescribed assessments, you are expected to be a lifelong learner and a ‘reflective practitioner’. The latter means taking time to think about events that you have been involved in (both positive and negative) and searching for the underlying lessons they can teach you. Reflective pieces in practice should be done at least once a month and uploaded to your ePortfolio. In some foundation schools, they are a mandatory requirement to pass the year and are easier to do monthly rather than have a huge number at the end of the year prior to your Annual Review of Competence Progression (ARCP). In order to improve recruitment practices in the United Kingdom, many programmes including the Foundation Programme are using situational judgement tests (SJTs) to assess job relevant behaviours and select the best candidates for any given post. SJTs consist of a series of hypothetical scenarios that you may encounter as a junior doctor. Questions are either ‘ranking questions’ where candidates rank five responses to a clinical scenario or ‘multiple-choice questions’ where candidates may choose the three most appropriate actions. These aim to test the candidates’ professionalism, communication, teamworking and coping with pressure. There are still many unanswered questions about the discriminatory power of SJTs and whether they represent a robust and reliable method for selecting trainees to UK training programmes. Many specialty training programmes however, including core medical training, are piloting the use of SJTs to assess recruitment into programmes. There are now a number of books and online resources dedicated to preparing candidates taking SJTs for postgraduate medical training. Selection into specialist training can differ markedly depending on your specialty choice. In addition, it is liable to change rapidly over the coming years. There are currently two main groups of specialties – those that have a period of core training (general surgery/core medicine/psychiatry/acute care common stem) followed by further competitive selection into subspecialties and those that are ‘run-through’ and do not have a stage of further selection. The latter includes specialties such as general practice, histopathology, neurosurgery, ophthalmology, microbiology, paediatrics, radiology, obstetrics and gynaecology and public health. For more information on the selection process, see http://www.medicalcareers.nhs.uk/. In terms of postgraduate exams, it is currently possible to enter for the first part of the MRCS (surgical membership) exam as soon as you are granted a medical certificate; the final part can then be completed whenever the candidate is ready. For MRCP (medical membership) you need at least 12 months experience (i.e. complete FY1) to enter the first part. Once this is completed you can again sit for the final two parts whenever you are ready. In the past, it was not encouraged for trainees to take postgraduate exams during foundation training. However, it is now compulsory for core medical trainees to complete all parts of the MRCP in order to fulfil requirements for their ARCP sign-off and be able to take up ST3 posts. It is therefore advisable to complete the MRCP as soon as you are able to. For the other specialties (anaesthetics, pathology, psychiatry, radiology emergency medicine, etc.), it is not usually possible to sit any exams until on a training programme. There are lots of diplomas that can be completed if you are itching to work on your postgraduate CV; the British Medical Journal (BMJ) careers section has good articles on most of them. Around a third of Foundation Programme graduates do not immediately progress to specialty training in the United Kingdom. Some choose to work and travel abroad in order to gain new work and life experiences. Australia is particularly popular as no entry exams are currently required, working hours are flexible and trainees report gaining more hands-on experience and enhancing their skills. Some trainees seek more clinical experience doing ‘trust grade’ posts in the United Kingdom – these posts can sometimes provide an advantage if the trainee chooses to apply to that specialty in the future or failed to secure a training post at the first attempt. Other valuable learning experiences include the National Medical Director’s Clinical Fellow Scheme where junior doctors can be seconded to organizations such as the Department of Health, the NICE or the Royal College of Physicians and develop skills in leadership, management and health policy. It is also possible for Foundation Programme graduates to pursue higher degrees (e.g. MD or PhD) or research experience before committing to specialty training. It is becoming impossible to practice medicine without a basic level of technical knowledge. Most people will be familiar with using computers for word processing, email and web surfing, but there is a lot more out there: Using the Internet in the NHS is fraught with precautions and limitations. All hospitals will have local policy about the level of Internet access and what is allowed. Be aware of these. A few pointers: NHS Evidence is a good starting point for clinical information. This includes useful resources like clinical pathways represented in the Map of Medicine (NHS-approved clinical flow charts) and Clinical Knowledge Summaries (formally Prodigy), a summary of evidence-based information provided for the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Take a little time to familiarize yourself with this NHS service – it is improving all the time! Other websites rich in online content are: The information and technology explosion is real. There are several ways to keep up to date with stacks of international journals with minimal fuss; we wish we had known about these when we were students! Evidence-based medicine is a central tenet of being a good doctor. Basically, evidence-based medicine involves using research findings to give clinicians much more statistical power in interpreting everyday clinical data rather than relying on anecdotal evidence. Not only do people who practice evidence-based medicine find that they become more aware – and critical – of research findings, but they quickly become adept at solving difficult problems and find that they can engage better in medical debates. Evidence-based medicine can be practiced by teams or by individuals. Evidence-based medicine involves carrying out three key steps: If in doubt, look it up and discuss with your seniors or ideally at a formal journal club. In addition to all the work directly involving patients, you should strongly consider getting involved in the other aspects of medicine. Not only is it a worthwhile learning experience, but also it is good on your CV and occasionally enjoyable! The amount of paperwork and the organizational obstacles can be very daunting but your seniors should be supportive. Clinical governance is increasingly important for all doctors. As a minimum, you should know what it means and how to go about the process of audit. Clinical governance is defined by the system through which NHS organizations are accountable for continuously improving the quality of their services and safeguarding high standards of care by creating an environment in which clinical excellence will flourish. It is traditionally classified in terms of the seven ‘pillars’: Clinical audit is simply the measurement of clinical practice against a specific standard and its effectiveness with the aim of improving it. It is useful to get involved in clinical audit as you will learn about management, common pitfalls and the difficulties in implementing change in a large organization. You can easily get involved in an existing audit by speaking to the relevant consultant or your hospital audit department. Alternatively, you can start a new one. Retrospective audits are generally easier to conduct than prospective ones unless your daily work overlaps with audit. You can start by looking at local or national guidelines that the service you work in should ideally meet. Then you need to decide how to measure whether the guidelines are being followed or the standards achieved. Here are some ‘tips’: The audit cycle involves the following steps: Step 1: Identify an issue or problem. Step 2: Set criteria and establish a ‘gold standard’. Step 3: Observe practice and collect data. Step 4: Compare performance with criteria and standards (data interpretation). Step 5: Make recommendations to implement change. Step 6: Re-audit to establish effectiveness of change and ‘close’ the loop. If the process is repeated again, it becomes an audit ‘spiral’. The GMC expects all doctors to take part in systems of quality assurance and quality improvement, and this forms part of the appraisal and revalidation process. Quality improvement projects aim to improve patient experience and outcomes using systematic change methods and through changing provider behaviour. Quality improvement projects use a plan-do-study-act cycle and aim to make a difference in a relatively short space of time rather than the traditional audit model. Successful quality improvement projects need to have specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound (SMART) goals. An example could be to improve weekend handover by introducing a patient pro forma with specific and relevant clinical information. There are a number of journals and conferences that encourage innovation and creative thinking to improve healthcare. You could consider submitting your completed project for publication in one of these journals (e.g. BMJ Quality and Safety) or present work at relevant conferences. There is an element of luck in writing a case report, since you need an interesting case to write about. However, a good case need not be a rare one; common cases can be just as good, especially if there were pitfalls in the diagnosis or management of the patient: A popular choice amongst trainees is to submit a case report article or clinical image (as a picture quiz) for BMJ Endgames. This is a weekly section published in the BMJ intended to help junior doctors prepare for their postgraduate examinations and professional development. Education is more than just working on the wards, attending grand rounds and reading books. There is a wide array of courses one can take on; these are regularly advertised in the BMJ careers classified sections and fall into several broad groups: Attending specialty courses can be used to demonstrate your commitment to a particular field when it comes to job applications, so it is useful to find out what may be available at an early stage. There are many good courses run throughout the year at the Royal Society of Medicine and the Royal Colleges (surgeons, physicians, anaesthetists, etc.), by BMJ Masterclasses and via local deaneries. It may be the case that no one ever specifically teaches you how to be a professional. Don’t worry if the transition from student to doctor is full of bumps and jolts – it certainly was for us. There isn’t much mystery to being ‘professional’; it’s mostly about communicating well, building relationships and being responsible for what you say and do. However, this is no small thing to accomplish. For an enjoyable job, good communication is essential. As a junior doctor, you may make about 10–15 phone calls for every patient you admit. You may interview up to 5000 people during the year. You will write volumes of notes that others will rely on and that might one day be used as evidence in court. You will physically touch thousands of people. Although most medical schools do teach communication or relationship skills, you are still supposed to largely pick them up from your seniors. As you have probably already observed, many seniors are lacking in personal and communication skills. It pays to develop your own skills; they will save you bleeps, headaches, time and lawsuits. Over 90% of UK medical defence cases result from poor communication rather than from negligence. Many so-called personality clashes between healthcare professionals, patients and relatives can be solved by effective and imaginative communication: You will talk and write to many GPs; some you will get to know quite well. The following are some recommendations from a number of GPs, including Joe Rosenthal, a GP who also teaches at the Royal Free Hospital in London: Don’t rely on the post! This can sometimes take weeks to reach a GP’s desk. It is crucial to get on with nurses, who are fantastic allies. They know most of what you need to know as a junior doctor and are usually keen and willing to teach you. Nurses are trained in a range of things that doctors aren’t and vice versa, so the teams are complementary – remember this and use it to your advantage! Here are some hints for starters:
BECOMING A BETTER DOCTOR
Foundation Programmes (United Kingdom)
Academic Foundation Programmes
Assessments
Situational judgement tests
Moving on from the Foundation Programme
Information technology
The Internet
Online medical databases
Keeping up with the literature
Evidence-based medicine
Clinical governance and paraclinical work
Clinical audit
Quality improvement projects
Case reports
Courses
Professionalism
Communication
Consultants and senior registrars
GPs
Nurses
Helpful things to know about nurses