Through the Lens of History: A Look at Vaccine-Preventable Disease and the Origin of Vaccines



Through the Lens of History: A Look at Vaccine-Preventable Disease and the Origin of Vaccines






In 1736 I lost one of my sons, a fine boy of four years old, by the smallpox taken in the common way. I long regretted bitterly and still regret that I had not given it to him by inoculation.

—Benjamin Franklin

Vaccination and vaccine-preventable disease have a long and storied past. Vaccine-preventable diseases have toppled empires and changed the face of history. (Box 1.1) It wasn’t until Edward Jenner’s (Figure 1.1) discovery of the first vaccine against smallpox in 1796 that we had some hope of fighting back against these devastating illnesses. The development of vaccines has been one of the greatest scientific advances in history, saving more lives than almost anything else we do in modern medicine. Thanks to vaccines, smallpox has been eradicated from the planet; today’s children no longer need immunization against smallpox as their grandparents did. Polio is no longer present in the United States and only occurs (and exceedingly rarely at that) in a few countries, with the hope of eradication in the near future. Many of today’s physicians have never seen a case of tetanus. Whether it is completely causally related or not, we have not had an influenza pandemic like the Spanish Flu of 1918, during which one-third of the world’s population was infected and an estimated 50 million people died (more than the number of people who died in all of World War I), since the introduction of the first influenza vaccine in 1938. The burden of vaccine-preventable disease has been reduced by 92% to 100% (depending on the disease in question)2 since the advent of vaccination. As a result, the world is a safer and healthier place to live.

However, more than 220 years since Jenner’s groundbreaking discovery, vaccine-preventable diseases are again on the rise. We are seeing tens of thousands of cases of measles in countries across Europe. In 2018, Queensland, Australia, saw its first death from diphtheria since 2011.3 In the United States, we have had measles outbreaks affecting hundreds of people in California, Ohio, Minnesota, New York, Washington, Oregon, and Texas, among others. In 2017, mumps returned to the Pacific Northwest, with 891 cases in Washington state alone.4 As of August of 2018, pertussis has sickened 260 people in Idaho, compared with just 32 cases for all of 2017.5 As it so happens, vaccines have become a victim of their own success. Our collective memory, at least when it comes to the devastation caused by vaccine-preventable disease throughout world history, is short. We are victims of an “out of sight, out of
mind” phenomenon. As a community, we no longer see these illnesses affecting our loved ones, so they no longer seem like an ever-present danger. Certain segments of our population have become complacent about immunizing, or turned away from it intentionally, and we are beginning to see a return of these vaccine-preventable illnesses in unvaccinated or undervaccinated communities as a result.







FIGURE 1.1 Edward Jenner is credited with developing the first vaccine. Jenner inoculated his first test subject with exudate from a cowpox lesion from the hand of a milkmaid, effectively protecting his subject against subsequent infection with smallpox. (Courtesy of Wellcome Library, London. Wellcome Images. Edward Jenner. Oil painting. wellcomecollection.org/works/ca86xk2y. CC BY 4.0)


Recalling the history of vaccines and vaccine-preventable disease is, therefore, exceedingly important to maintaining our vigilance around immunization. Our history informs our present and our future. If we don’t have a clear knowledge of that history, we risk repeating our past, an out-come that could prove deadly. This chapter offers a brief overview—thousands of years of history condensed into a few pages—of the history of vaccines and vaccine-preventable diseases. We will look at devastating historical illnesses like smallpox, polio, and influenza. We will review a timeline of the discovery of vaccines through our modern-day immunization campaigns. We will recall the darker side of vaccination through history and how this has potentially colored people’s views of vaccines and of government involvement with immunization recommendations. Finally, this chapter will bring us to present day and to the illnesses that are resurfacing in our communities, thanks to decreasing rates of vaccination.


SMALLPOX, VARIOLATION, AND THE FIRST VACCINE

Smallpox, named for the numerous pus-filled blisters (or pocks) that it caused on those infected with the disease, was one of the greatest scourges in human history. The earliest evidence of its devastation is seen on mummified remains from the Egyptian dynasties (1570-1085 bc). Chinese writings from 1122 bc and Sanskrit texts from India are some of the earliest written recordings of the illness.6 Smallpox traveled with settlers and merchants and made its way to Europe sometime around the fifth to seventh centuries. It was epidemic at various points throughout the Middle Ages and played an important role in the development of Western civilization. The Plague of Antonine killed nearly 7 million people and coincided with the beginnings of the fall of the Roman Empire. When Spanish and Portuguese conquistadores came to the New World, they brought smallpox with them, an introduction that was instrumental in the destruction of the great Aztec and Incan empires. Settlers on the eastern coast of North America introduced the native population to smallpox. It was later used as one of the first examples of biological warfare when the British used smallpox to kill off the “hostile” American Indian population during the French and Indian War.

The earliest efforts at inoculation against this deadly disease were first documented in China and the Middle East in the 15th century. Writings describe a process later named “variolation,” whereby scabs from a person infected with smallpox (variola virus) were dried and powdered then introduced to a healthy person via nasal insufflation (blowing the powdered pox into the nose) or during which pustular matter was taken from an infected person and introduced to a healthy individual via scratches in the skin. Smallpox carried a 20% to 60% fatality rate. However, the process of variolation itself resulted in death for 1% to 2% of those on which it was used and had the potential to cause outbreaks if those infected spread the disease to others. This process was continued with varying success through the ages and across continents, finally making its way to England and North America with the slave trade in the 1700s.7 However, as we still see today, albeit with much safer inoculation methods, the process of conferring immunity faced opposition. Injecting healthy people with a potentially fatal disease to induce a lesser case of illness and hopefully prevent more serious and deadly consequences was a hard pill to swallow (Figure 1.2).







FIGURE 1.2 This illustrated cartoon from 1804 shows the unease and lack of understanding surrounding the smallpox vaccination. This sentiment still prevails today and hinders the deployment of effective vaccination programs. (Courtesy of the National Library of Medicine.)

It wasn’t until the early to mid-1800s that variolation was largely abandoned in favor of a process termed “vaccination.” The father of vaccination was an English physician scientist named Edward Jenner. Although he was not the first to observe that milkmaids infected with cowpox had immunity to smallpox, nor likely the first to test the observation, he was the first to disseminate results of his studies to the world and, thus, gains credit for the discovery. In 1796, to test his theory, Jenner used the matter from a milkmaid’s cowpox lesion to infect his test subject, a boy named James Phipps. Cowpox is a member of the orthopoxvirus family, as is smallpox. However, cowpox is a much milder and generally nonfatal disease. Phipps came down with a mild illness but quickly recovered. Jenner then injected his subject with smallpox and found that Phipps never became ill. He repeated this exposure several times and Phipps remained immune. Thus was born the world’s first vaccine, a term derived from the Latin word for cowpox (vaccinia),6 a milestone that set us on the path to ultimate worldwide eradication of the virus in 1980, following a global immunization campaign led by the World Health Organization.


PANDEMICS IN RECENT HISTORY

More modern history recalls other deadly pandemics. In 1918, the world saw the greatest pandemic in centuries. The Spanish flu, so named for the reports of its particular devastation in Spain, a country not subject to the news blackouts that affected other countries during wartime, swept across the continents, killing 50 million people world-wide (with some estimates as high as 100 million). It killed even more people than
died during World War I (which claimed an estimated 16 million lives). One-third of the world’s population was infected. Most families were touched by loss, for some, many times over. The average life expectancy was diminished by 12 years during that one flu season as a result of this particularly virulent influenza strain.8 Moreover, in an unusual fashion, the Spanish flu had a predilection for killing younger, healthier individuals sometimes within hours, their lungs filling with fluid and blood causing suffocation and death.

The influenza virus was not identified until 1933, and the first vaccine wasn’t introduced until 1938. However, that initial vaccine and those soon to follow were only variably successful. The reasons for this, we ultimately discovered, were the multiple strains of influenza and the propensity of those influenza strains to mutate, changing their anti-genic (infectious) properties as rapidly as from the time it takes to produce the vaccine to the time it is administered. Influenza can even mutate during the production phase, when it is being grown in its most common growth medium, the chicken egg. New methods of production, which are less prone to mutation, are in development, and we have hopes of a more universal flu vaccine in the future. However, for now, our current flu vaccine is the best way to decrease the chances of infection with influenza and its severe and potentially deadly consequences.

Even more recently, we may recall the polio epidemics that ravaged the United States and other parts of the world. Polio is a virus that is spread rapidly by close per-sonal contact, through secretions from the mouth and nose, or by contact with contam-inated feces. Although polio did not uniquely affect children, the name initially used to describe the condition (infantile paralysis) hints at its greater impact on the very young. Not everyone suffered so severely. In fact, nearly 95% of people had no symptoms of their infection at all. However, when the virus did impact the nervous system, resulting in a paralysis of the muscles including those muscles required for breathing, it caused devastating results. In a single year (1952), nearly 60,000 US children were infected with the polio-virus. Thousands were permanently paralyzed, and 3000 children died.9 It’s not difficult to find photographs from the United States in the 1950s that show children walking with braces, children with withered legs from the muscle atrophy that resulted from infection, and rows upon rows of iron lungs used to keep those whose breathing muscles had become paralyzed alive. Between 2% and 5% of children infected with the paralytic form of polio would ultimately die of their disease. Although fewer adults were affected, their prospects were even more dismal with up to 15% to 30% with paralytic polio dying of complications of their illness.10

In the 1900s, as vaccine science progressed, building upon the lessons learned from early immunization development, production, and large-scale vaccine deployment, the medical and lay worlds saw a growing number of available vaccines (Table 1.1). It is important to recognize here, and to be able to express to our questioning patients, that vaccinations are not produced for illnesses that are “not that severe,” as those who oppose vaccines would claim. There are no vaccinations against the common cold or hand, foot and mouth disease, for example. That is because these infections very rarely cause illness severe enough to require hospitalization, leave permanent brain or other organ damage, or result in death. Immunizations are produced against those illnesses that have the propensity to cause significant risk to life. For example, in the United States, “in 1920, 469,924 measles cases were reported, and 7575 patients died; 147,991 diphtheria cases were reported, and 13,170 patients died. In 1922, 107,473 pertussis cases were reported, and 5099 patients died.”11 On a worldwide scale, this represents the loss of millions of lives. Immunizations are developed to fight against some of the greatest killers of children and others across the globe.









TABLE 1.1 Vaccine-Preventable Diseases by Year of Vaccine Development or Licensure in the United States (1798-2018)11














































































































































DISEASE


YEAR


Smallpoxa,d


1798b


Rabiesd


1885b


Typhoidd


1896b


Cholerad


1896b


Plagued


1897b


Diphtheriaa


1923b


Pertussisa


1926b


Tetanusa


1927b


Tuberculosisd


1927b


Influenza


• IIVa


1945c


• LAIVa


2003c


Yellow feverd


1953c


Poliomyelitis


• IPVd


1955c


• Enhanced-potency IPVa


1987c


• OPVd


1962c


Measlesa


1963c


Mumpsa


1967c


Rubellaa


1969c


Anthraxd


1970c


Meningococcal disease


• MPSV4d


1974c


• MenACWY-Da


2005c


• MenACWY-CRMa


2010c


• MenB


2014/15c


Pneumococcal disease


• PPSV14d


1977c


• PPSV23


1983c


• PCV7d


2000c


• PCV13a


2010c


Adenovirusd


1980c


Hepatitis Ba


1981c


Haemophilus influenza type ba


1985c


Japanese encephalitisd


1992c


Hepatitis Aa


1995c


Varicellaa


1995c


Lyme diseased


1998c


Rotavirusa


1998c


Human papillomavirus (HPV)


• HPV4d


2006c


• HPV2d


2009


• HPV9a


2014c


Zoster (shingles)


• Zostavaxd


2006c


• Shingrix


2018c


a Vaccine recommended for universal use in the US children.

b Vaccine developed (ie, first published results of vaccine usage).

c Vaccine licensed for use in United States.

d Either discontinued (for example, routine smallpox vaccination was discontinued in the United States in 1971) or not recommended for routine use in the United States.


IIV, inactivated influenza vaccine; IPV, inactivated polio vaccine; LAIV, live attenuated influenza vaccine; MenACWY, meningococcal conjugate vaccine, strains A, C, W, and Y; MenB, meningococcal conjugate vaccine, strain B; MPSV, meningococcal polysaccharide vaccine; OPV, oral poliovirus vaccine; PCV, pneumococcal conjugate vaccine; PPSV, pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Mar 16, 2020 | Posted by in GENERAL & FAMILY MEDICINE | Comments Off on Through the Lens of History: A Look at Vaccine-Preventable Disease and the Origin of Vaccines
Premium Wordpress Themes by UFO Themes
%d bloggers like this: